Feb 28, 2024 Leave a message

Preventing Peeling Defects on Hot-Rolled Wear-Resistant Plate

What Peeling Actually Looks Like on a Hot-Rolled Wear Plate

On a hot-rolled abrasion-resistant plate such as NM400 or NM450 to GB/T 24186, the defect usually described by buyers as peeling, sliver or scab appears as a thin flap of metal that is partly detached from the surface, leaving a shallow elongated depression underneath. The flap may be torn away during handling, leaving a stepped edge with a bright metallic bottom. Adjacent areas often show a line of non-metallic inclusion stringers exposed along the roll direction, and the defect elongates as the plate is rolled, so its long axis follows the rolling direction. It is not a coating failure: wear plate is normally supplied bare or primed, and a coating that flakes off is a completely different claim.

The practical significance is disproportionate to the surface area affected. Even a small peeled patch acts as a stress raiser and as a trap for abrasive slurry in a chute liner or bucket lip; the flap can break away in service and the resulting pit accelerates local wear. For a plate sold against a specified surface quality class, the defect is a rejection item, and for a fabricator it becomes scrap once the plate has been cut and drilled. Because the root cause usually originates in continuous casting rather than in the rolling mill, the defect cannot be inspected out at the finishing line; it has to be prevented upstream.

Root Cause Chain: Gas Bubbles, Inclusions and the Casting Skin

The defect mechanism that dominates in practice is entrapment of gas and inclusion-laden steel just below the solidifying shell in the mould. Argon introduced through the stopper rod for flow control and nozzle protection partly dissolves into the steel and partly forms bubbles. When the argon flow is too high, or when it exits asymmetrically around the stopper head, bubbles detach and rise, disturbing the meniscus. Bubbles that reach the meniscus are entrapped by the solidifying shell and, together with the mould flux and any alumina or spinel inclusions they carry, are rolled into a subsurface band. On subsequent hot reduction that band forms a plane of weakness a few tenths of a millimetre to a few millimetres below the original surface, and the material above it separates as a flap.

Two related mechanisms produce a similar appearance and should be distinguished before corrective action is chosen. The first is mould flux entrapment caused by meniscus level fluctuation: the slag rim that forms at the meniscus is folded into the shell during a level recovery, producing a slag-rich layer that peels during descaling. The second is nozzle clogging and subsequent alumina flushing, which delivers a burst of solid inclusions into the mould exactly when the flow field is most disturbed. A defect investigation that assigns all peeling to one mechanism will usually leave half the occurrences untouched.

Steelmaking and Deoxidation Before the Caster

Cleanliness at the caster is bought in the ladle and the tundish. For a wear plate in the 400 HBW class, total oxygen in the tundish is commonly targeted below 20 ppm and the aim is a low population of large inclusions above 50 micrometres. That is achieved by full aluminium deoxidation with slag of controlled basicity and low iron oxide plus manganese oxide content, adequate soft argon stirring time in the ladle, and calcium treatment to modify solid alumina into calcium aluminates that remain liquid at casting temperature and do not clog the nozzle. Calcium treatment must be matched to sulphur level; an over-treated heat with high sulphur forms calcium sulphides that cluster and produce a different family of surface defects.

Process stage Parameter to control Typical target Failure mode if missed
Ladle furnace Total oxygen before casting Below 20-25 ppm at tundish Large alumina clusters, subsurface slivers
Ladle furnace Slag iron oxide plus manganese oxide Below about 1.5% combined Reoxidation, inclusion re-growth
Calcium treatment Calcium to sulphur ratio and inclusion modification Liquid calcium aluminate, no solid clusters Nozzle clogging, alumina flushing into mould
Tundish Depth of steel above the nozzle Minimum operating depth maintained Vortexing, slag entrainment, argon carry-over
Ladle change Ladle heel before change Minimum level retained, slag detection active Slag carry-over into tundish, mould flux disturbance

Reoxidation anywhere between ladle, tundish and mould destroys the benefit of a clean start. Air ingress through a poorly sealed shroud, a porous tundish lining that has not been properly dried, or a stopper rod joint that leaks will generate fresh alumina, and fresh alumina is precisely the material that builds on the nozzle bore and later breaks away.

Stopper Rod Argon, Shroud Practice and Bubble Behaviour

Argon flow through the stopper rod serves two purposes: it prevents steel from penetrating the joint and it helps keep the nozzle clear. Both are served by the minimum effective flow, not the maximum. Excessive flow creates a bubble swarm that crosses the meniscus and is entrapped by the solidifying shell; too little flow allows steel to enter the joint, where it freezes and later breaks off as a foreign body. Many casters operate in the range of about 1 to 3 litres per minute per stopper rod and adjust the value by grade, casting speed and nozzle bore. The important discipline is that the flow is verified per strand and per sequence, not set once and forgotten.

Bubble behaviour depends on where the argon leaves the refractory. Argon emerging from a joint gap on one side of the stopper head produces a large asymmetric plume and a correspondingly asymmetric level disturbance; argon distributed around the stopper head through a porous ring produces finer bubbles that are more easily floated out in the tundish or absorbed at the meniscus. The submerged entry nozzle design and its port angle determine where the jets land in the mould and how the meniscus is fed, which in turn determines whether bubbles are carried down the narrow face or allowed to escape. A stopper change or a nozzle change is therefore a process change and should be followed by a first-heat surface inspection rather than by a full sequence of production.

Mould Level Stability and Casting Speed Discipline

Almost every peeling event can be traced to a transient: a ladle change, a tundish change, a speed change, a nozzle change or a start-up. During these transients the meniscus level moves, the slag rim is disturbed, and the shell that forms at that moment is contaminated. Stability is therefore the objective, and stability is achieved by keeping the steel level within a narrow band, typically plus or minus 3 to 5 mm in the mould, and by making speed changes in small increments with the level controller given time to respond.

Ladle change is the highest-risk transient. Keeping the tundish level above its designed minimum during the change preserves the flow field and reduces the chance of vortex formation and slag entrainment; the ladle must be changed before its own level drops far enough to carry slag through the tundish. Slag detection systems, whether electromagnetic or based on vibration or thermal signatures, exist for this purpose and should be interlocked with the ladle gate rather than used only as a record. Argon injected at the ladle shroud and the tundish upper nozzle must be stable through the change; a step change in argon pressure at that moment is a common cause of the level excursion that produces the defect.

Mould Flux, Oscillation and the Surface It Leaves Behind

Mould flux controls heat transfer, lubrication and inclusion absorption. A flux with excessive viscosity or a shallow slag pool fails to absorb the inclusions floating to the meniscus, so they are re-entrained. A flux that is not replaced at the correct rate becomes depleted of its absorbing capacity and its melting behaviour drifts, which shows up as increased oscillation mark depth and a rougher as-cast surface. Oscillation mark depth also depends on stroke, frequency and negative strip time; deep marks are stress raisers that open during rolling and can connect a subsurface inclusion band to the surface.

Flux choice must match the steel: the higher carbon and micro-alloyed chemistry used in wear plate changes the peritectic position and thus the shell shrinkage behaviour, so a flux optimised for a low-carbon grade will not deliver the same uniform shell. When peeling appears on one grade and not another on the same machine, the flux and the secondary cooling pattern are the first two suspects, not the rolling mill.

Reheating, Descaling and Rolling: Where Defects Become Visible

A subsurface band of inclusions can survive casting without becoming visible. It becomes a visible peel in the reheating furnace or at the descaler. Furnace atmosphere control matters: excessive residence time at high temperature with high oxygen and moisture produces thick, adherent scale and decarburisation, and the interface between scale and steel becomes irregular. Primary descaling at 180 to 220 bar removes the furnace scale, but a defect that has already opened at the inclusion band will be enlarged by the water jets, and the flap will lift. Secondary descaling before the finishing stands is only effective if the secondary scale is thin and broken; if the interstand time is long and the scale is thick and ductile, the descaling headers will not remove it and it is rolled in as a rolled-in scale defect that mimics a peel.

Roll practice contributes a separate family of defects that are often mislabelled. Worn or spalled work rolls transfer their pattern to the plate; a build-up on the roll surface can indent and tear the surface; excessive reduction in a single pass with a cold, badly shaped slab produces edge laps and, in severe cases, surface folding. The diagnostic that separates mill-induced from caster-induced peeling is location and distribution: caster-induced peels are scattered and associated with inclusion stringers, while roll-induced marks repeat at the roll circumference or concentrate on the drive side.

Observed feature Most probable origin Verification action
Flap with exposed inclusion stringers, randomly scattered Gas bubble and inclusion entrapment in mould Review argon flow records, mould level traces and tundish cleanliness for the affected sequence
Defect aligned with oscillation marks, one face only Mould flux depletion or excessive level fluctuation Check flux consumption per tonne and level controller response at transients
Repeat pattern at fixed pitch along the plate Work roll condition or roll build-up Cross-check with roll change records and neighbouring plates from the same campaign
Dark, smeared patches with no flap Rolled-in secondary scale Review interstand time, descaling pressure and finishing temperature
Longitudinal edge laps Slab shape, width reduction or edging practice Inspect slab corner condition and edger settings

Inspection, Disposition and Acceptance Criteria

Surface quality of hot-rolled plate is assessed visually and dimensionally, with general requirements such as those in ASTM A6/A6M and the delivery requirements of GB/T 17505 providing the framework; for wear plate the grade requirements come from GB/T 24186, and thickness tolerances from EN 10029 where that standard is invoked. Mechanical verification follows GB/T 228.1 for tensile properties, GB/T 229 for impact energy and GB/T 232 for bend, with chemical analysis by GB/T 4336 or an equivalent method. Internal soundness, where specified, is checked by ultrasonic testing to GB/T 2970.

Disposition should be agreed before the first plate is inspected, not after a claim. A workable specification states the maximum acceptable depth of a peel relative to nominal thickness, whether grinding repair is permitted, the minimum remaining thickness after grinding, and the surface roughness and flatness requirements after repair. A common industrial approach allows isolated surface defects to be removed by grinding provided that the ground area is smoothly blended, that remaining thickness stays above the minimum permitted by the dimensional standard, and that no defect is exposed to a depth greater than a stated fraction of thickness. Anything deeper, or any defect associated with cracking, is rejected because grinding a stress raiser out of a wear part may restore appearance while leaving a thinned section in the highest-wear zone.

Ordering practice should also fix the hardness test location and method, since surface decarburisation from reheating can lower a surface reading by several HBW. Testing on a ground surface at a defined depth, with the number and position of indentations stated, prevents the argument that a soft reading is a defect when it is in fact a measurement artefact.

FAQ

Q: What causes peeling on hot-rolled wear-resistant plate?
The dominant cause is entrapment of argon bubbles and inclusion-laden steel just below the solidifying shell in the continuous casting mould, which forms a subsurface plane of weakness that opens as a flap during rolling.

Q: How does stopper rod argon flow affect surface quality?
Excess argon produces a bubble swarm that crosses the meniscus and is captured by the shell, while too little allows steel to enter the joint and later break away; most casters therefore run a verified low flow of roughly 1 to 3 litres per minute per rod.

Q: Why is ladle change the highest-risk moment for this defect?
Because tundish level, argon pressure and flow field all change at once, and any level excursion disturbs the meniscus and folds slag or bubbles into the solidifying shell.

Q: Can peeling be removed by grinding and the plate still be accepted?
Only if the acceptance criteria permit it, the defect is isolated, the ground area is smoothly blended and the remaining thickness stays above the minimum required by the applicable dimensional standard.

Q: How can a buyer tell caster-induced peeling from a roll mark?
Caster-induced peels are scattered, carry inclusion stringers and align with the rolling direction, whereas roll-induced marks repeat at a fixed pitch tied to roll circumference or concentrate on one side of the plate.

Q: Which standards apply when verifying a wear plate delivery?
Grade requirements from GB/T 24186 for NM400, NM450, NM500 and NM550, thickness tolerances from EN 10029 when invoked, tensile and impact testing to GB/T 228.1 and GB/T 229, bend testing to GB/T 232, and ultrasonic testing to GB/T 2970 where internal soundness is specified.

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

phone

Email

Inquiry