Mar 22, 2024 Leave a message

ASTM-A516-A516M Standard Specification.pdf

SA516 Gr.60 vs Gr.70: Strength, Chemistry and Selection

What ASTM A516/A516M Covers and Why Two Grade Names Appear

ASTM A516/A516M is the standard specification for carbon steel plates intended for pressure vessels in moderate and lower-temperature service. The same document is adopted into the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code as SA-516/SA-516M in Section II, Part A, which is the reason a single plate may be described as "A516 Gr.70" in one purchase order and "SA516 Gr.70" in the next. The "S" prefix carries no extra metallurgical requirement: it signals that the specification is acceptable for code-stamped construction, with general requirements supplied by ASTM A20/A20M (SA-20/SA-20M) covering tolerances, surface quality, marking, sampling and test methods.

The specification defines three carbon-manganese grades: Grade 60, Grade 65 and Grade 70. None of them relies on deliberate alloy additions. Strength is obtained from carbon and manganese within tight ceilings, from controlled rolling practice, and - where the order demands it - from normalising. The consequence for buyers is simple but often overlooked: Grade 60 and Grade 70 are not different steel families, they are adjacent points on the same strength ladder, and the correct choice is decided by design stress, thickness, toughness requirement and fabrication sequence rather than by a preference for "stronger" plate.

Reading the Grade Numbers Correctly

The number in Grade 60, 65 and 70 is the specified minimum tensile strength expressed in kilopounds per square inch (ksi). Grade 60 therefore means 60 ksi minimum tensile, which is approximately 415 MPa; Grade 70 means 70 ksi minimum tensile, approximately 485 MPa. The number is not a yield strength, not a hardness, and not a carbon content. Confusion on this point is the most common source of mis-specified plate in pressure vessel procurement, and it leads to designers comparing the wrong rows of the mechanical property table.

Yield strength, elongation and chemistry are specified separately for each grade. A Grade 70 plate is not produced by taking Grade 60 and adding carbon at will; the carbon and manganese ceilings rise only slightly, and the practical difference in strength comes largely from microstructural control and, where applicable, from heat treatment condition. A mill cannot legally supply "Grade 70" on the strength of a tensile test alone if the chemistry and the specified delivery condition do not match as well.

Chemical Composition: Where the Three Grades Separate

Composition limits in A516 are written as a function of plate thickness, and they tighten as the section grows. The table below summarises the composition windows normally applied to plate up to about 2 in. (50 mm); thicker plate carries revised carbon and manganese bands, so the purchase order should always state the thickness, the specification edition and any supplementary requirement rather than quoting a grade name alone.

Element Grade 60 (typical limits, plate to 2 in.) Grade 65 Grade 70
Carbon, max 0.21% (0.23% above 1/2 in.) 0.24-0.26% depending on thickness 0.27-0.28% depending on thickness
Manganese 0.60-0.90% 0.85-1.20% 0.85-1.20%
Silicon 0.15-0.40% 0.15-0.40% 0.15-0.40%
Phosphorus, max 0.035% 0.035% 0.035%
Sulphur, max 0.035% 0.035% 0.035%
Typical carbon equivalent (IIW) 0.33-0.38 0.38-0.42 0.40-0.45

Two practical readings follow from this table. First, phosphorus and sulphur are capped rather than specified as ranges, so a heat that sits at 0.030% P and 0.028% S is fully compliant but materially less tough and less weldable than one at 0.012% P and 0.005% S; buyers who care about through-thickness ductility or Charpy performance should add a restricted chemistry requirement, not just order the grade. Second, the carbon equivalent climbs from roughly 0.35 in Grade 60 to roughly 0.43 in Grade 70, which is precisely why welding procedure qualification for Grade 70 plate frequently requires a higher preheat than the procedure used on Grade 60 of the same thickness.

Mechanical Properties Side by Side

Mechanical requirements are stated as tensile strength range, minimum yield strength and minimum elongation. The upper tensile limit matters as much as the lower one: a heat that over-strengthens the plate makes it harder and less ductile, and code calculations assume the material stays inside the specified band. Elongation is measured on a 2 in. (50 mm) gauge length for plate up to 2 in.; thinner or thicker material may be tested on a different proportional gauge, so the certified value must be read against the gauge length actually used.

Property Grade 60 Grade 65 Grade 70
Tensile strength, ksi (MPa) 60-80 (415-550) 65-85 (450-585) 70-90 (485-620)
Yield strength, min, ksi (MPa) 32 (220) 35 (240) 38 (260)
Elongation in 2 in., min 21% 19% 17%
Typical as-supplied hardness 130-165 HBW 140-175 HBW 150-185 HBW
Typical carbon equivalent 0.33-0.38 0.38-0.42 0.40-0.45

The 6 ksi gap in yield between Grade 60 and Grade 70 (about 40 MPa) looks modest in isolation, but it enters the design calculation directly: allowable stress for a given temperature is derived from tensile strength divided by a safety factor and from yield divided by a second factor, and the governing value is the lower of the two. For a shell in moderate-temperature service, moving from Grade 60 to Grade 70 typically allows either a thinner wall at constant design pressure or a higher design pressure at constant wall thickness, which is where the real cost trade-off sits. The counterweight is that thinner Grade 70 plate may fall below the minimum thickness at which the fabrication shop's rolling, welding and non-destructive examination procedures were qualified, and that Grade 70 needs tighter welding control.

Delivery Condition, Thickness and Heat Treatment

A516 plate is ordered in one of several delivery conditions: as-rolled, stress-relieved, or normalised. For heavier sections the specification calls for normalising, and normalised plate is routinely specified whenever the vessel will operate below ambient or will be subject to impact testing. Normalising refines grain size, which raises toughness and slightly reduces the scatter in tensile results; it also adds cost and lead time because the plate must be re-austenitised and cooled in air rather than simply rolled and cooled.

Thickness tolerances come from A20/A20M rather than from A516 itself, and the permitted minus tolerance is a function of nominal thickness and width. A plate ordered "25 mm" may legitimately arrive at the permitted minimum, and if the design calculation was run on the nominal figure the corrosion allowance has effectively been reduced before the vessel enters service. Buyers should state the minimum thickness required after tolerances, and should require that the certified thickness be measured at the prescribed locations rather than at a single point chosen by the mill.

Plate is normally supplied in widths and lengths cut to the order, with sheared or flame-cut edges. Flame-cut edges on Grade 70 heavier than about 2 in. are usually required to be inspected for edge cracks, and hard flame-cut edges may need to be machined or ground before welding. Surface condition requirements in A20/A20M permit certain imperfections to be removed by grinding within defined limits; repairs by welding require agreement and are normally restricted to specified depth and area.

Impact Toughness and Low-Temperature Service

The base A516 specification does not, by itself, impose Charpy V-notch impact testing. Where toughness matters, the buyer must invoke either a supplementary requirement or a purchase-order requirement that defines test temperature, energy absorption, lateral expansion and the number of specimens per heat or per plate. This is the single most common gap between what a designer assumes and what the mill certificate actually proves: a Grade 70 plate certified to the base specification has demonstrated tensile strength, yield strength, elongation and chemistry, and nothing about notch toughness.

For vessels operating at low temperature, the practical route is often to move to a low-temperature specification such as GB/T 3531 grades (16MnDR, 09MnNiDR) or to specify impact testing at a defined temperature on the A516 order. Grade for grade, lower carbon and lower sulphur improve the transition temperature; normalising improves it further; and the highest-strength grade is not automatically the best choice for cold service, because higher carbon and manganese raise the ductile-to-brittle transition range. A Grade 60 normalised plate with restricted sulphur will usually outperform a Grade 70 as-rolled plate in a Charpy test at minus 20 degrees C, even though its tensile strength is lower.

Welding and Fabrication Differences That Affect Cost

Both grades are readily welded by shielded metal arc, gas metal arc, submerged arc and flux-cored processes, but the workmanship variables are not identical. The higher carbon equivalent of Grade 70 means preheat becomes mandatory rather than optional as thickness increases; a common shop practice is a preheat in the 100-150 degrees C band for Grade 60 above about 25 mm and 150-200 degrees C for Grade 70 at similar thickness, with interpass temperature controlled so that the heat input stays within the qualified range. Low-hydrogen consumables and dry electrode storage are standard requirements, not optional refinements.

Post-weld heat treatment is frequently required for pressure vessel construction, typically in the 590-650 degrees C range with controlled heating and cooling rates and hold time scaled to thickness. Grade 60 responds predictably; Grade 70, being closer to the carbon ceiling, loses a little more strength during the hold, and the procedure qualification must demonstrate that the welded joint still meets the specified tensile and yield values after the thermal cycle. A welding procedure that passed on Grade 60 plate should not be assumed to transfer to Grade 70 without re-qualification if the essential variables - thickness, preheat, heat input, PWHT - change.

Which Grade to Specify: A Buyer's Decision Sequence

The decision is best taken in a fixed order rather than argued case by case. First, fix the design temperature range and confirm whether impact testing is required; if it is, the toughness requirement drives grade and heat treatment condition before strength is considered. Second, fix the design pressure and allowable stress basis, and compute required thickness for each candidate grade. Third, check whether the resulting thickness is inside the qualified range of the shop's welding and forming procedures. Fourth, cost the two options including heat treatment, welding consumables, preheat labour and any additional examination the higher grade attracts. Fifth, decide whether a restricted chemistry (low sulphur, low phosphorus, controlled carbon equivalent) is worth adding to reduce fabrication risk.

In practice Grade 70 is specified for the majority of moderate-temperature process vessels because it delivers the thinnest economic wall. Grade 60 remains the sensible choice where the vessel is small, where the wall is governed by minimum thickness rules rather than by stress, where cold forming is extensive, or where the shop's qualified procedures and the client's inspection regime are built around the lower-carbon material. Specifying Grade 70 "for safety margin" on a vessel whose wall is set by a minimum-thickness clause buys nothing and adds welding cost.

Inspection, Certification and Acceptance

A pressure vessel plate order should define the inspection document before the plate is rolled. The usual requirement is a mill test report showing heat number, grade, thickness, delivery condition, product analysis, tensile and yield results, elongation, and the results of any impact or additional tests ordered, traceable to the plate identification marking. Third-party inspection documents conforming to EN 10204 type 3.1 are commonly requested where the end user requires independent verification of the test results against the heat.

Acceptance checks at goods-inward should include: verification that the grade, heat number and delivery condition on the marking match the certificate; dimensional check of thickness at the specified points, width, length and squareness; visual inspection of surfaces and cut edges against A20/A20M limits; confirmation that any repair grinding is within permitted depth; and, where required, review of the heat treatment chart for normalised or stress-relieved plate. Retained samples or the ability to re-test from the same heat should be confirmed in the order, because a failed fabrication trial on a plate that cannot be traced back to a test piece is an expensive way to discover a documentation gap.

Storage, Handling and Traceability on Site

Carbon steel pressure plate is stored flat on cribbing clear of the ground, with edge protection to prevent flame-cut corners from being damaged during lifting. Plate identified for low-temperature or impact-tested service should be kept separately and its marking preserved; painted grade and heat markings are commonly lost during blasting, so the fabricator should transfer the identification to a controlled traveler before surface preparation begins. Plate that has been normalised should not be subjected to local heating for straightening without engineering approval, since uncontrolled thermal input can undo the grain refinement that was paid for.

FAQ

Q: Is SA516 Gr.60 the same material as A516 Gr.60?
The chemistry and mechanical requirements are the same document family; "SA" indicates adoption into the ASME code, with general requirements taken from SA-20/SA-20M rather than A20/A20M. A plate certified to one is normally acceptable for the other provided the purchase order and the code of construction align.

Q: What is the minimum yield strength of SA516 Gr.70?
38 ksi, approximately 260 MPa, with a specified tensile range of 70-90 ksi (485-620 MPa) and minimum elongation of 17% in 2 in. for plate up to 2 in. thick.

Q: Does A516 Gr.70 include Charpy impact testing as standard?
No. Base A516 does not impose impact testing. Toughness must be added by supplementary requirement or purchase-order clause specifying test temperature, minimum absorbed energy and lateral expansion, and the sampling frequency.

Q: Why is Grade 70 harder to weld than Grade 60?
Because its carbon and manganese ceilings are higher, raising carbon equivalent to roughly 0.40-0.45. That requires higher preheat, tighter interpass control, low-hydrogen consumables and often re-qualification of the welding procedure, particularly when post-weld heat treatment is applied.

Q: Can Grade 60 and Grade 70 plate be mixed in one vessel?
They can, but the design calculation must be run for each region using the allowable stress of the grade actually used there, and the welding procedure must be qualified for the higher-carbon material. Mixing grades also complicates impact testing and traceability, so it is normally confined to nozzles, repads and small internals.

Q: What thickness tolerance applies to A516 plate?
Tolerances are taken from ASTM A20/A20M and depend on nominal thickness and width, with a permitted minus tolerance that can be significant on heavier plate. The order should specify minimum thickness after tolerances if the design calculation is based on nominal wall.

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

phone

Email

Inquiry