Short Answer: Same Family, Different Strength Class
Both EN 10025-6 and ASTM A514/A514M describe quenched and tempered alloy steel plate intended for welded structures, and both use a designation in which a number stands for a strength property. They are not equivalent grades, however, because the numbers mean different things and the specified strength levels differ substantially. ASTM A514/A514M is built around a minimum yield strength of 690 MPa, which is 100 ksi, with a tensile strength range of 760 to 895 MPa for the standard plate grades and a maximum thickness of 150 mm. EN 10025-6 S960Q requires a minimum yield strength of 960 MPa with a tensile strength of 980 to 1150 MPa for thickness up to 50 mm. A supplier who treats one as a drop-in replacement for the other is comparing a 690 MPa steel with a 960 MPa steel.
The confusion arises because the two systems use strength classes differently. In the ASTM system the grade letter, not the number, identifies the composition: A514 is a single standard with grades A to S covering different chemistries and thickness capabilities, all within the same strength band. In the European system the number in the grade name is the minimum yield strength, and a single chemistry family is stretched across the S460Q to S960Q ladder by alloy and processing control.
Grade-by-Grade Comparison
| Property | ASTM A514/A514M plate grades | EN 10025-6 S960Q |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum yield strength | 690 MPa | 960 MPa |
| Tensile strength | 760–895 MPa | 980–1150 MPa |
| Maximum specified thickness | 150 mm | Thickness tables extend with reduced properties; nominal class quoted to 50 mm |
| Delivery condition | Quenched and tempered | Quenched and tempered |
| Designation logic | Grade letter denotes chemistry | Number denotes minimum yield strength |
| Closest European match | S690Q class | No ASTM grade in the A514 band |
Read in that direction the comparison becomes clear. The European grades that sit in the same strength class as A514 are the S690Q family, not S960Q. Conversely, a project that genuinely needs 960 MPa minimum yield strength has no ASTM A514 equivalent at all and must either specify the European grade directly or use a proprietary quenched and tempered product with a project-specific specification.
Why the Numbers Are Not Interchangeable
Three design consequences follow from the strength difference. Compressive and buckling resistance scales with the square root of yield strength, so a 960 MPa plate delivers far less than a proportional gain in slender member capacity. Ductility and elongation fall as strength rises, which restricts the use of the highest classes in plastic design and in structures that must absorb seismic energy. Weldability becomes more demanding because the carbon equivalent and the heat-affected zone behaviour of a 960 MPa steel require a tighter welding procedure, controlled heat input and verified hardness and toughness. A substitution in either direction therefore has to be assessed by the design engineer, not by the purchasing department, even where both plates are quenched and tempered and both are welded constructional steels.
When Each Specification Is the Right Choice
ASTM A514/A514M suits heavy welded structures that need high strength with a generous thickness capability and a long-established supply base: earthmoving and mining equipment, crane and excavator components, pressure vessel supports and heavy transport frames. Its grades are widely available in thicknesses well beyond 50 mm, which is a real advantage where a thick section must carry a concentrated load. EN 10025-6 S960Q suits weight-critical designs where every kilogram matters and the sections are comparatively thin: mobile crane booms, concrete pump arms, lifting equipment frames and lightweight structural members. The choice is driven by the thickness and the actual stress level, not by the appeal of the higher number.
How to Specify a Substitution Correctly
If a substitution is unavoidable, the specification should carry the required minimum yield strength, the tensile range, the impact test temperature and absorbed energy, the maximum carbon equivalent and the delivery condition, and it should state the allowable thickness range with the properties required at that thickness. Simply naming a grade from another system is not enough, because the two systems distribute their requirements across grades and thickness tables in different ways. Impact testing and hardness checks on the procedure qualification weld should be required in every case, since the heat-affected zone is where a poorly matched substitution fails.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is S960Q a direct equivalent of ASTM A514?
A: No. A514/A514M requires a minimum yield strength of 690 MPa with a tensile strength of 760 to 895 MPa, while S960Q requires a minimum yield strength of 960 MPa with a tensile strength of 980 to 1150 MPa. They are in different strength classes.
Q: Which European grade is closest to ASTM A514?
A: The S690Q class of EN 10025-6, with a 690 MPa minimum yield strength, is the closest match. The S690QL variant adds low-temperature impact toughness.
Q: How thick can these plates be supplied?
A: ASTM A514/A514M covers plate up to 150 mm, with properties specified by grade and thickness. EN 10025-6 properties fall as thickness increases, and S960Q is normally applied to material up to 50 mm.
Q: Can the two grades be welded with the same procedure?
A: No. Each material needs its own qualified welding procedure with appropriate preheat, heat input and consumables, and hardness and toughness verification on the qualification record.
Q: Does the higher strength grade always reduce weight?
A: Only where strength governs the design. Deflection, buckling and fatigue limits, along with the unchanged modulus of elasticity, mean the weight saving is usually smaller than the strength ratio suggests.
Q: What should a substitution specification contain?
A: Minimum yield strength, tensile range, impact test temperature and energy, maximum carbon equivalent, delivery condition, and the properties required at each thickness. Naming a grade alone does not transfer these requirements.




