Feb 28, 2024 Leave a message

Tension Stratification Control in High Strength Ship Plate

Tension stratification is a through-thickness defect that appears in tensile test specimens of high strength ship plate. Instead of a uniform ductile fracture, the broken specimen splits along the centre line of the plate thickness, and the measured elongation drops below the level required by the specification. Because the plate may then be rejected even though its surface quality and general mechanical properties are acceptable, controlling the phenomenon has become a routine task in the production of high strength hull steel.

What tension stratification looks like

The split is not a surface defect and it is not a crack that propagates from an edge. It is a separation that follows the mid-thickness plane of the plate, where the last part of the slab to solidify during continuous casting is located. During the tensile test the specimen necks in the usual way, but a plane of weakness inside the section opens up before the final fracture, so the fracture face shows a flat, discontinuous split instead of a fully fibrous surface. The heavier the section and the higher the strength class, the more visible the effect becomes.

Metallurgical causes

Metallographic and fractographic examination of rejected specimens shows that the defect always traces back to the centre of the slab. Four features occur together in most cases:

Unclosed or insufficiently rolled porosity at the centre of the slab, known as centre looseness.

Segregation of carbon and manganese along the centre line of the thickness, which produces a local band of hard, low ductility material.

Banded manganese sulfide inclusions (MnS) elongated in the rolling direction and lying flat in the mid-thickness plane.

Composite inclusions in which MnS is combined with aluminium oxide (Al2O3) and titanium oxide (TiO2), creating large, angular particles that act as crack initiation sites.

When these features are aligned in a plane perpendicular to the through-thickness tensile stress, they form a continuous path of low cohesion. The tensile test then opens the plane rather than tearing the matrix around it, and the specimen fails by stratification.

Sulfur control and inclusion modification

Hull structural steel is a manganese-bearing steel: at a manganese content of about 1.0 %, sulfur has a strong tendency to combine with manganese and form MnS. Two steps are used to limit the damage.

Reduce sulfur as far as the steelmaking route allows. For high strength hull grades the aim is to keep sulfur below 0.005 %, which sharply reduces both the number and the size of sulfide inclusions.

Modify the shape of the remaining inclusions by feeding calcium silicon wire into the ladle. The calcium reacts with the sulfides and changes them from elongated, deformable MnS strings into globular calcium-rich inclusions that stay small and remain rounded during rolling. Rounded inclusions interrupt the matrix far less than long bands, so the tendency to split is reduced.

The treatment is normally supported by calcium and sulfur ratio control plus adequate soft argon stirring after wire feeding, so that the modified inclusions can float out of the melt before casting begins.

Continuous casting practice

Casting parameters decide how much centre segregation and centre porosity the slab carries into the rolling mill, so they are the second control lever.

Superheat: on a thick slab caster, low superheat pouring is used whenever the nozzle condition permits. The target superheat window is 15 to 25 degrees centigrade, which widens the equiaxed zone and narrows the columnar zone.

Casting speed: the withdrawal speed is kept moderate at 0.9 to 1.1 m per minute, since a higher speed deepens the liquid pool and worsens centre segregation.

Secondary cooling: a stronger cooling regime limits the growth of columnar crystals, raises the proportion of equiaxed grains and reduces centre segregation and centre porosity.

Electromagnetic stirring: stirring in the secondary cooling zone homogenises the residual liquid, lowers the segregation tendency of carbon and manganese and reduces centre looseness.

Heating and controlled rolling

The last stage happens in the reheating furnace and on the rolling line, where the segregated structure can be partly diffused and the internal voids welded shut.

Soaking: a higher soaking temperature together with sufficient soaking time allows segregated carbon and manganese to diffuse, which softens the centre line before rolling.

Opening temperature: the initial rolling temperature is generally held in the range of 1100 to 1180 degrees centigrade so that deformation starts while the centre of the slab is still soft.

Reduction: an increased total reduction and heavier passes raise the through-thickness strain, close internal voids produced during casting and reduce the plane of weakness in the finished plate.

Controlled cooling: during accelerated cooling the carbon in the manganese-depleted zones transforms from austenite to ferrite before it can diffuse back into the manganese-rich bands, so the banded ferrite and pearlite structure is suppressed and the centre line stays more homogeneous.

Verification and acceptance testing

Tensile testing is carried out on full thickness specimens in accordance with GB/T 228.1 so that the fracture face can be inspected for centre splitting.

Ultrasonic testing of the plate body, following GB/T 2970 or the applicable classification society requirement, detects internal discontinuities and lamination-type indications.

Macro-etching of a transverse section from a cast sample shows the equiaxed ratio, the extent of centre segregation and the severity of centre looseness.

Sulfur printing and inclusion rating on rolled samples confirm that sulfide morphology has been modified rather than simply reduced in number.

Impact testing at the specified design temperature verifies that the tougher centre structure has not been obtained at the expense of toughness elsewhere in the plate.

Frequently asked questions

Q: What exactly is tension stratification in ship plate?
It is a separation along the mid-thickness plane of a tensile specimen, caused by internal defects in the centre of the plate. It shows up as a split fracture face and frequently as reduced elongation in the tensile test.

Q: Why is sulfur the first element to control?
Sulfur combines with the manganese that is deliberately added to hull steel and forms manganese sulfide inclusions. At high sulfur levels these inclusions are long and deformable, so they roll out into flat bands in the centre of the plate and create the plane along which the specimen splits.

Q: How does calcium silicon wire treatment help?
The calcium modifies the sulfide inclusions and converts them into small, globular particles. Rounded inclusions disturb the surrounding matrix far less than elongated bands, which reduces the tendency of the plate to separate during tensile testing.

Q: Which casting parameters matter most?
Low superheat in the range of 15 to 25 degrees centigrade, a moderate withdrawal speed of 0.9 to 1.1 m per minute, stronger secondary cooling and electromagnetic stirring. Together they increase the equiaxed grain ratio and reduce centre segregation and centre porosity.

Q: How does controlled rolling reduce the defect?
Heavy reduction at an opening temperature around 1100 to 1180 degrees centigrade welds internal porosity closed and increases through-thickness strain, while accelerated cooling suppresses the banded ferrite and pearlite structure that would otherwise form at the segregated centre line.

Q: Can the defect be detected before delivery?
Yes. Tensile test fracture faces, ultrasonic testing of the plate body, macro-etching of a cast sample and inclusion rating on rolled samples together give a reliable picture of the internal quality before the plate leaves the works.

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

phone

Email

Inquiry