Tempering, Precipitation and the 2200 MPa Strength Class
Secondary hardening is the strength increase that follows tempering of a quenched martensitic steel in the intermediate temperature range instead of the classical low-temperature range. In a low-carbon Fe-Co-Ni-Cr-Mo-W plate, tempering between about 470 °C and 540 °C replaces coarse cementite with a fine dispersion of M2C alloy carbides, which lifts the strength of the plate into the 2200 MPa class while keeping enough toughness for highly loaded structural duty. Because the strength is generated by a precipitation reaction and not by a high carbon content, the plate keeps carbon low, so users gain weldability and forming capability that a plain carbon-hardened steel of the same strength could not provide.
Test Material, Instrumentation and Analysis Method
The behaviour described here was established on a Fe-Co-Ni-Cr-Mo-W test steel investigated by scanning electron microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, high-resolution transmission electron microscopy and physicochemical phase analysis. The combination matters: SEM and TEM reveal where the precipitates sit relative to the martensitic lath structure, HRTEM resolves the crystal structure of the carbide and its orientation relationship with the matrix, and physicochemical phase analysis quantifies the mass fraction of each element inside the extracted carbides. Mechanical properties were tracked in parallel, so every precipitate state could be linked to a measurable strength or toughness value instead of being described only by metallography.
Tempering Temperature versus Tensile and Yield Strength
The test steel shows pronounced secondary hardening across the intermediate tempering range. Tensile strength peaks at 2243 MPa after tempering at 490 °C, while yield strength peaks at 1859 MPa after tempering at 530 °C. The optimum overall balance appears at 510 °C, where tensile strength is 2185 MPa, yield strength is 1859 MPa and impact energy is 35 J. That balance, rather than the single highest tensile figure, is normally what a structural plate specification should target, because it preserves a usable level of impact energy at a strength of about 2200 MPa.
| Tempering temperature | Precipitate state | Reported mechanical response |
|---|---|---|
| 400-440 °C | Numerous thick lamellar cementite particles inside the martensitic laths and at the lath boundaries | Below the secondary-hardening peak |
| 470 °C and above | Fine M2C carbides plus a small amount of Laves phase Fe2W | Secondary hardening becomes dominant |
| 490 °C | Fine M2C dispersion, peak number density | Tensile strength peak at 2243 MPa |
| 510 °C | Fine M2C carbides with Fe2W | Tensile 2185 MPa, yield 1859 MPa, impact 35 J |
| 530 °C | Early coarsening of the M2C dispersion | Yield strength peak at 1859 MPa |
Identification of the hardening phases. Below roughly 470 °C the dominant precipitate is cementite. It forms as thick lamellae inside the martensitic laths and at the lath boundaries, and because it is coarse it contributes little to strength. Once the tempering temperature exceeds about 470 °C the microstructure changes decisively: large numbers of fine M2C carbides appear together with a minor amount of Laves phase Fe2W. The fine M2C dispersion is the direct cause of the secondary-hardening peak, because a high number density of small particles is an effective barrier to dislocation motion, whereas the coarse cementite of the lower range is not.
Composition Drift Inside the M2C Carbide
Raising the tempering temperature also changes the chemistry of the M2C carbide itself: the mass fraction of molybdenum and tungsten inside M2C increases, while the mass fraction of iron and chromium decreases. This is the expected behaviour of a strongly carbide-forming alloy system. As the elements become more mobile, the carbide rejects the weaker carbide formers and enriches in the elements that give it the highest thermodynamic stability, so the particle becomes both a more effective strengthener and more resistant to coarsening. Heat treaters can therefore use tempering temperature as a process lever, because the precipitate chemistry, and with it the stability of the strengthening dispersion, follows directly from that single set point.
Practical Implications for Plate Supply and Fabrication
Specify the tempering temperature, not only the strength level. A 2200 MPa tensile requirement can be met at 490 °C, but the toughness reserve is better at 510 °C.
Protect the fine M2C dispersion. Any later thermal exposure above the tempering range will coarsen the carbides and remove the secondary-hardening contribution.
Control the welding thermal budget. Moderate heat input keeps the heat-affected zone from being over-tempered, which is the usual location of strength loss in this class of plate.
Confirm properties on the delivered thickness. Thicker plate cools more slowly during quenching, so the hardening response must be verified on a sample of the actual section rather than on thin laboratory stock.
Report tensile, yield and impact results together. Strength alone does not describe a precipitation-hardened plate; impact energy at the same tempering condition is equally part of the specification.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the peak strength of this secondary-hardening plate?
Tensile strength reaches 2243 MPa after tempering at 490 °C, and yield strength peaks at 1859 MPa after tempering at 530 °C.
Q: Which precipitates cause the hardening?
Fine M2C alloy carbides that form above about 470 °C; a small amount of Laves phase Fe2W is present alongside them.
Q: What happens between 400 °C and 440 °C?
Thick lamellar cementite precipitates inside the martensitic laths and at the lath boundaries, so the strength stays below the secondary-hardening peak.
Q: Why is 510 °C tempering often preferred over the peak-strength condition?
It delivers 2185 MPa tensile strength, 1859 MPa yield strength and 35 J impact energy, a better toughness balance than the maximum tensile condition.
Q: How does the carbide chemistry change with tempering temperature?
The mass fraction of molybdenum and tungsten in M2C rises as the tempering temperature increases, while the mass fraction of iron and chromium falls.
Q: Which methods were used to characterise the precipitates?
SEM, TEM, HRTEM and physicochemical phase analysis were combined with mechanical testing of tempered specimens.




