Two Materials, Two Different Corrosion Problems
The phrase corroded steel plate is a translation artefact. What the specification actually means is hydrogen-sulphide corrosion resistant plate, a low-alloy pressure-vessel steel produced with tightly controlled phosphorus and sulphur, calcium-treated for inclusion shape control, and qualified by hydrogen-induced cracking testing so that it can survive wet H2S service in refineries and petrochemical plants. Weathering steel is a completely different family: a structural steel alloyed with copper, chromium and nickel that is deliberately allowed to rust in the atmosphere because the rust layer it forms becomes dense, adherent and protective.
Placing the two side by side is useful precisely because they look similar in a warehouse and behave in opposite ways. One is designed to resist a specific chemical attack from inside a wet, sour process environment and must never be judged by its appearance. The other is designed to oxidise on the outside and is judged almost entirely by how that oxidation progresses. Confusing them leads to two expensive mistakes: using a weathering grade in wet H2S service, where it has no qualification at all, and using a hydrogen-induced cracking resistant plate outdoors unpainted, where its low sulphur chemistry offers no atmospheric advantage over ordinary structural steel.
Any selection discussion therefore has to begin with the environment rather than the grade name, and with the governing standard rather than the trade description. Wet sour service is a code compliance question answered by NACE MR0175 / ISO 15156 and by the purchaser's additional cracking test requirements. Atmospheric exposure is a design question answered by ISO 9223 corrosivity categorisation together with GB/T 4171, ASTM A588/A588M, EN 10025-5 or JIS G 3125, depending on the market.
What Wet H2S Actually Does to Steel Plate
In wet sour service, hydrogen sulphide dissociates and supplies atomic hydrogen at the steel surface. Part of that hydrogen diffuses into the metal instead of recombining at the surface, and it collects at inhomogeneities: elongated manganese sulphide inclusions, banded segregation, hard transformation products in the heat-affected zone. When the local hydrogen pressure exceeds the cohesive strength of the interface, a planar crack opens parallel to the rolling direction. Neighbouring cracks link through the thickness and produce the stepwise pattern that gives hydrogen-induced cracking its name. On the outside this may show only as surface blisters; the internal damage is invisible from the plate face and cannot be detected by a visual inspection or by thickness measurement.
A second mechanism, sulphide stress cracking, is a delayed brittle failure under applied or residual tensile stress, and it is controlled primarily by hardness and by heat treatment rather than by cleanliness. A third, stress-oriented hydrogen-induced cracking, combines both and appears in the heat-affected zone of welds where hardness and residual stress coincide. The practical point for a plate buyer is that resistance cannot be bought by chemistry alone: it comes from low sulphur and low phosphorus, from inclusion shape control by calcium treatment, from a normalising or normalising-plus-tempering delivery condition that avoids hard bands, and from welding procedures that keep heat-affected zone hardness below the ceiling set by the standard.
Because the failure is internal and progressive, the plate is qualified by destructive testing of a sample rather than by a certificate of composition. The purchaser specifies the test standard, the solution, the exposure time and the acceptance criteria, and the mill reports the result for that heat. That is the fundamental difference from a structural or weathering grade, where chemistry and mechanical properties alone usually close the acceptance loop.
H2S-Resistant Plate: Chemistry, Cleanliness and Test Regime
These plates are usually supplied against a base pressure-vessel grade - Q245R or Q345R under GB/T 713, SA516 Gr. 70 under ASME BPVC Section II Part A, or an equivalent - with an additional sour-service annex. The base grade fixes the tensile and impact requirements; the annex fixes the steelmaking route and the cracking tests. Thickness ranges up to roughly 180 mm are routinely produced, and heavy sections above 100 mm are where the metallurgical difficulty concentrates, because centre-line segregation has less chance to be worked out during rolling.
Typical compositional controls applied on top of the base grade are sulphur at 0.003 percent maximum or lower, phosphorus at 0.010 percent maximum or lower, and a calcium-to-sulphur ratio in the treated steel high enough to convert elongated manganese sulphide into globular calcium sulphide inclusions that do not act as crack nuclei. Carbon equivalent is kept modest to support field welding without excessive preheat, and the plates are normally supplied normalised, or normalised and tempered, with a documented heat treatment cycle. A carbon equivalent around 0.40 or below is common for sour-service heavy plate, and any figure above that should trigger a welding procedure check rather than an automatic rejection.
| Parameter | Typical sour-service requirement | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Sulphur | 0.003% max, often 0.002% max for heavy plate | Removes elongated sulphide inclusion nuclei for hydrogen cracking |
| Phosphorus | 0.010% max | Limits centre-line segregation and temper embrittlement |
| Inclusion shape control | Calcium treatment, Ca/S ratio controlled | Converts Type II sulphides to globular, non-cracking shapes |
| Delivery condition | Normalised or normalised plus tempered | Avoids hard bands and reduces residual stress |
| HIC test | NACE TM0284, solution A, commonly CLR 15% / CTR 5% / CSR 2% max | Quantifies through-thickness cracking in the rolled plate |
| SSC test | NACE TM0177, Method A tensile in solution A or B | Confirms resistance to stress cracking at specified stress level |
| Hardness | Typically 200 HBW or 22 HRC max in base metal and HAZ | Keeps the metal below the threshold for sulphide stress cracking |
The three HIC ratios deserve explanation because they are frequently quoted without context. Crack length ratio is the total length of cracks measured on a cross-section divided by the section width; crack thickness ratio is the summed crack thickness divided by the section thickness; crack sensitivity ratio is the total cracked area divided by the examined area. A plate that passes all three still requires a qualified welding procedure, because the test characterises the rolled product, not the heat-affected zone of a field weld.
Weathering Steel: Alloying Design and the Stable Rust Layer
Weathering steel achieves atmospheric corrosion resistance by forming a rust layer that becomes compact and largely impermeable after an initial weathering period, instead of the loose, flaky scale that forms on ordinary carbon steel. The alloying philosophy is a small addition of copper, typically 0.25 to 0.55 percent, combined with chromium, nickel and sometimes phosphorus, together with a grain-refining and strength contribution from manganese. The chemistry is deliberately low-alloy, which is why the material remains weldable and affordable, and why it is supplied in ordinary plate thicknesses for bridges, buildings, transmission towers and rolling stock.
The grades follow regional standards. GB/T 4171 covers the Q235NH, Q355NH and Q500NH series, with high-phosphorus variants such as the Q355GNH type intended for improved weathering performance in non-welded or lightly welded applications. ASTM A588/A588M covers Grades A, B and C, and ASTM A606 covers thin sheet and coil in the same family. EN 10025-5 supplies S235J0W, S355J0W and S355J2W, and JIS G 3125 covers SPA-H and SPA-C. Mechanical property requirements are generally aligned with the corresponding structural grades, so a Q355NH plate is specified with the strength of Q355 and the corrosion resistance of the weathering family.
The critical engineering constraint is that the protective rust layer only forms under alternating wet and dry conditions with adequate time to dry. In continuously wet, buried, immersed, or chloride-rich conditions the layer never stabilises, and weathering steel then corrodes at a rate comparable to, or worse than, ordinary carbon steel because it has no protective coating at all. This is why the material is unsuitable for immersion service, for the splash zone, for areas with de-icing salt exposure without protection, and for details that trap water and debris. Design detailing, drainage and ventilation matter as much as the steel grade itself.
Property and Application Comparison
| Characteristic | H2S corrosion resistant plate | Weathering steel plate |
|---|---|---|
| Governing standard | Base grade per GB/T 713 or ASME BPVC II-A, plus NACE MR0175 / ISO 15156 and purchaser HIC annex | GB/T 4171, ASTM A588/A588M, ASTM A606, EN 10025-5, JIS G 3125 |
| Design intent | Survive wet sour process fluid without cracking | Form a stable, protective rust layer in open atmosphere |
| Key chemistry | Very low S and P, calcium treated, low carbon equivalent | Cu 0.25-0.55%, plus Cr, Ni, sometimes P for enhanced grades |
| Thickness | Commonly 8-180 mm, heavy plate capability matters | Mainly 3-100 mm plate and coil |
| Surface finish | Usually painted or lined; bare surface is not the protection | Deliberately unpainted, allowed to rust uniformly |
| Testing emphasis | HIC and SSC destructive testing, hardness survey, UT for laminations | Tensile, impact, bend, plus optional cyclic corrosion testing |
| Typical service | Refinery columns, separators, sour water strippers, gas treating vessels | Bridges, transmission towers, rail wagons, exposed architectural structures |
| Failure mode if misused | Internal stepwise cracking, blistering, sudden brittle failure | Accelerated general corrosion and pitting where the rust layer cannot stabilise |
Read across the table and the logic is clear. The first material is a pressure-retaining grade whose qualification is chemical, metallurgical and destructive. The second is a structural grade whose qualification is mechanical and whose performance depends heavily on exposure conditions and detailing. Neither is a superior version of the other; they answer different questions.
Welding and Fabrication Differences
For sour-service plate the welding procedure is part of the material qualification, not a downstream detail. Heat input must be controlled to avoid hard, untempered martensite in the heat-affected zone, preheat is normally applied for thickness above about 25 mm, and consumables must be low in sulphur and diffusible hydrogen. Hardness surveys on procedure qualification test pieces, typically at the weld metal, fusion line and coarse-grained heat-affected zone, verify that the specified ceiling is met. Post-weld heat treatment may be required for thickness or service reasons, and where it is applied the holding temperature and cooling rate must be recorded. Repair welding is treated with the same discipline; an unqualified field repair in a sour-service vessel is a credible initiation site for sulphide stress cracking.
Weathering steel welding is closer to ordinary structural practice, with one additional rule: the weld metal and the surrounding heat-affected zone must weather to a colour similar to the parent plate, otherwise the joint becomes a visible stripe and, worse, a corrosion cell. Matching consumables are specified by the steel supplier for exposed architectural work, and welds are usually ground flush and blended. Where a weathering structure is painted for appearance or for chloride exposure, the paint system follows standard structural practice and the alloying addition offers a useful secondary benefit if the film is damaged.
Forming and cutting are comparatively similar, but the sour-service plate is normally cut and formed before the final heat treatment check, and any hot forming must be followed by a heat treatment that restores the specified delivery condition. Weathering steel can be cold formed and cut without special measures, although thick sections benefit from preheat in cold weather as with any structural grade.
Selection Guide and Common Misapplications
Choose a hydrogen-sulphide resistant plate when the steel will be in contact with wet sour process fluid, when partial pressure of H2S and the presence of free water place the duty inside the scope of NACE MR0175 / ISO 15156, or when the purchaser's own specification calls for HIC testing irrespective of the calculated severity. In those cases the alloy content is not the deciding variable; the cleanliness, the inclusion shape, the heat treatment and the documented test results are.
Choose a weathering grade when the structure is exposed to the open atmosphere, drains freely, is ventilated, and is not subject to sustained chloride or moisture. Bridges over roads with heavy de-icing salt use, coastal structures within a few hundred metres of the shoreline, and any detail forming a water trap are outside the comfortable working envelope of bare weathering steel and normally require a protective coating system instead.
Three misapplications recur often enough to be worth stating explicitly. First, treating a low-sulphur plate as if low sulphur alone conferred sour-service qualification: without the shape-controlled inclusions, the heat treatment and the cracking test, the risk of internal damage remains. Second, leaving a weathering structure unpainted in a sheltered, dirty or permanently damp location where the rust layer cannot cycle wet and dry, which produces staining and progressive loss of section. Third, painting a sour-service vessel with a system chosen for atmospheric exposure without checking chemical compatibility with the process fluid, which converts a metallurgical solution into a coating failure waiting to happen.
Acceptance, Documentation and Verification
For sour-service plate, the documentation set should include the heat number, ladle and product analysis with sulphur and phosphorus reported to three decimal places, the calcium treatment record, the delivery condition with the heat treatment cycle, the tensile and impact results, the HIC test report stating the standard, solution, exposure time and the three crack ratios, the SSC test report where specified, and the ultrasonic examination report for laminations where the purchaser requires it. Incoming inspection should verify the heat number stamping against the certificate and check thickness and flatness; a plate that has been re-rolled or re-heat-treated outside the qualified route loses its qualification regardless of what the certificate says.
For weathering steel the documentation set is simpler: certificate of analysis showing copper and chromium, mechanical test results, and a declaration of the standard applied. Verification at receipt focuses on grade marking, dimensions and surface quality, plus confirmation that the plate has not been supplied as an ordinary structural grade under a weathering description. The difference in copper content is easy to check by analysis and is the most reliable single discriminator.
In both cases the specification should be written in the language of the applicable standard, with the edition and the test method named, so that the mill, the fabricator and the end user are discussing the same requirement. A purchase order that says sour service without naming a test standard and acceptance criteria leaves the most important property undefined.
FAQ
Q: Is weathering steel a type of corrosion resistant steel plate for H2S service?
No. Weathering steel resists atmospheric corrosion through a stable surface rust layer. It carries no HIC or SSC qualification and is not accepted for wet sour process service under NACE MR0175 / ISO 15156 unless specifically qualified by testing and by the purchaser.
Q: Why is low sulphur so important in H2S-resistant plate?
Sulphur forms manganese sulphide inclusions that are rolled into long, thin plates. Those plates act as hydrogen traps and crack initiation sites. Reducing sulphur to 0.003 percent or below and calcium treating the steel to make the remaining inclusions globular removes the main geometric cause of hydrogen-induced cracking.
Q: Can H2S-resistant plate be used unpainted outdoors?
It can, but there is no advantage in doing so. Its corrosion resistance is metallurgical and directed at wet sour internal service; atmospheric durability is not improved relative to ordinary structural steel. External surfaces of such vessels are normally coated with a system suited to the site corrosivity category.
Q: What do the HIC acceptance ratios CLR, CTR and CSR mean?
Crack length ratio is measured crack length divided by section width, crack thickness ratio is summed crack thickness divided by section thickness, and crack sensitivity ratio is cracked area divided by examined area. Common procurement limits are 15 percent, 5 percent and 2 percent respectively, measured per NACE TM0284 on a section taken after the specified exposure.
Q: Does a weathering steel bridge need painting?
Only where the environment prevents a stable rust layer from forming, for example under sustained chloride exposure, in sheltered damp locations, or in details that trap debris and water. Where painting is chosen, the system follows standard structural practice and the alloy addition provides extra tolerance to mechanical damage.
Q: How can a buyer tell the two materials apart on delivery?
By certificate and by analysis. A sour-service plate must come with a heat number, a product analysis reporting sulphur and phosphorus at low levels, a stated delivery condition and a HIC test report. Weathering steel is identified by the copper and chromium content and by the grade designation under GB/T 4171, ASTM A588/A588M, EN 10025-5 or JIS G 3125. Surface appearance alone is not evidence of either.




