Mar 04, 2024 Leave a message

8% Cr and Matrix Cold Work Tool Steels: Grades, Properties

Where the 8% Cr and Matrix Grades Sit in the JIS Tool Steel System

Japanese tool steels are organised by application family rather than by a single property table. JIS G 4401 covers carbon tool steels, JIS G 4404 covers alloy tool steels, and JIS G 4403 covers high speed tool steels. Inside JIS G 4404 the alloy tool steels are split into cutting tool steels, impact resisting tool steels, cold working die steels and hot working die steels. The cold working die group is the one that governs blanking, piercing, forming, coining, shear and trim tooling, and it is also the group that has produced the largest number of derivative grades that never entered the standard at all.

For a die builder or a purchasing engineer, catalogues from different mills describe the same conceptual steel in three layers: the standard JIS grade, a so-called improved grade positioned against it, and a speciality grade carrying a mill trade name. The trade name is commercially convenient but metallurgically empty. Any serious comparison therefore has to be rebuilt from four measurable things: chemical composition, carbide type and distribution, tempering response, and hardenability at the section size actually being purchased. The grades discussed below are the ones most frequently encountered when a drawing specifies a Japanese cold work die steel and the mill offers a non-standard substitute.

8% Cr Cold Work Steel: Why Lower Carbon and Lower Chromium Beat Higher Ones

The 8% Cr family is a deliberate step down from the classic 12% Cr high carbon grade represented by SKD11, which is nominally a 1.5C-12Cr-1Mo steel. The 8% Cr derivative is built on approximately 1C-8Cr-2Mo. Reducing carbon from about 1.5% to about 1.0% and chromium from about 12% to about 8% cuts the volume fraction of coarse primary M7C3 chromium carbide sharply, and that single change is responsible for most of the property shift.

The motivation was never cosmetic. When hardened and tempered die blocks are cut by electrical discharge machining, the machined surface is left with a recast white layer plus an underlying heat affected zone. The recast layer is typically a few micrometres to several tens of micrometres deep and is hard, brittle and untempered; the heat affected zone beneath it may run to roughly a tenth of a millimetre depending on the generator settings. Cracking initiates in this composite layer when the tensile residual stress from quenching is still high and the substrate toughness is marginal. Two remedies exist: remove the damaged layer mechanically, or temper at a temperature high enough to relax quenching stress. The second route is only usable if the steel still reaches working hardness after a high temperature temper.

That is exactly the gap the 8% Cr grade fills. With 12% Cr and 1.5% C, high temperature tempering over about 500 C destroys the as-quenched hardness and the tool cannot be brought back to the 60 HRC class. With 8% Cr plus about 2% Mo, secondary hardening from fine alloy carbide precipitation is strong enough that a double temper in the 500-530 C range still delivers roughly 62 HRC. The result is a die that can be stress relieved after EDM without losing its working hardness. Wear resistance is measurably below the 12% Cr grade because abrasive resistance in tool steel scales with total hard carbide volume; toughness, bend strength and resistance to edge chipping are clearly better. For that reason the 8% Cr grade is normally treated as a parallel standard, not a downgrade, and it is frequently the preferred choice for heavy section dies, dies with thin walls, and dies that will be EDM finished after hardening.

Matrix Stamping Die Steel: Pushing the Carbide Size Down Again

Matrix die steel continues the same logic one step further. Chromium is dropped into roughly the 3-5% range and carbon into roughly the 0.5-0.6% range, with molybdenum and vanadium added to preserve tempering resistance and grain refinement. At that composition the coarse eutectic carbide network of the 12% Cr steel is essentially gone, and what remains is a fine, uniformly dispersed carbide population in a matrix that is close to the composition of the matrix phase itself, which is where the name comes from.

The property consequences are easy to state and easy to measure. Coarse carbides act as stress concentrators and as crack initiation sites; removing them raises transverse toughness, bend strength and fatigue limit at identical hardness. Machinability improves because the tool no longer fights large carbide particles, and dimensional change on quenching becomes both smaller and less anisotropic, so a block that is milled oversize distorts predictably instead of warping in one direction. Practical gains appear as shorter delivery for finished dies, fewer correction passes after hardening, and longer life where the dominant failure mode is chipping or cracking rather than abrasive wear.

The trade-off must be stated honestly: with only 3-5% Cr and under 0.6% C, total carbide volume is far lower than in SKD11, so resistance to abrasive sheet, coated stock or filled polymer is inferior. Matrix grades are the right answer for high cycle blanking and forming of mild and high strength sheet where edge spalling governs life; they are the wrong answer for abrasive sheet or for tools that wear by scratching. Hardness is normally specified in the 60-62 HRC range after tempering, and the grade is not listed in JIS G 4404, so the purchase order must carry the actual composition limits rather than a grade symbol alone.

5% Cr Cold Work Steel and the Tempering Ceiling of SKD12

SKD12 is the standard 5% Cr member of the family, nominally 1C-5Cr-1Mo and broadly comparable to the A2 type used in North American practice under ASTM A681. Because carbon and chromium are both lower than in SKD11, the coarse carbide load is reduced and toughness is better, while abrasive wear resistance falls below the 12% Cr grade. Its real technical distinction is low anisotropy of dimensional change during hardening: blocks stay square and flat, which matters for long, narrow punches and for dies assembled from multiple plates.

The limitation is tempering response. SKD12 is typically austenitised around 970 C and can reach roughly 60 HRC after a low temperature temper in the 150-200 C range, but a high temperature temper above about 500 C leaves hardness below 58 HRC. In other words it cannot be stress relieved after hardening without sacrificing hardness, so it is a poor choice for dies that will be EDM finished in the hardened condition or that must survive a high temperature coating cycle. Within Japanese production practice this is precisely why the grade is encountered less often than its toughness would suggest.

Flame and Induction Surface Hardened Die Steel

Surface hardened die steel is a different concept: it is designed to be used without a full through-hardening treatment. The workpiece is finish machined first, then only the working edge is heated with a flame nozzle or an induction coil and quenched in place to above 60 HRC, leaving a tough, unhardened core behind the case. The economics are attractive for large trim dies, because no vacuum furnace cycle and no post-hardening correction are needed.

The metallurgical requirements are specific and they explain the composition. The steel must have a wide austenitising window so that hand-held heating does not over- or under-austenitise the surface; it must have enough hardenability to form martensite at the cooling rates achievable by a spray quench; it must be tough in the core; and it must tolerate the thermal gradients without cracking. A composition around 0.7C-1Si-1Mn-1Cr satisfies this combination, and the grade is not included in JIS G 4404. Case depths typically run from about 1.5 mm to 4 mm depending on travel speed and quench intensity, and hardness falls progressively into the core. These steels are commonly used for trim and cut-off dies in automotive body panel lines and for large forming dies where a fully hardened tool block would be uneconomic.

Grade Comparison for Specification and Quotation Review

The table below summarises representative values used for first-pass comparison. Composition figures are typical mid-range values, not specification limits; hardness figures assume the recommended austenitising and tempering practice on a test coupon. Always confirm the actual limits on the mill certificate before releasing a die programme.

Grade / family Typical composition Austenitising Quench Tempered hardness Dominant carbide Typical duty
SK105, carbon tool steel 1.05C, 0.2Si, 0.25Mn 750-800 C Water 60-63 HRC at 150-200 C Fine M3C Gauges, small punches, hand tools
SKS93, low alloy 1.05C, 0.95Mn, 0.4Cr 780-820 C Oil 60-62 HRC M3C plus fine alloy carbide Shear edges, gauges
SKS3, low alloy 0.95C, 1.0Mn, 0.75Cr, 0.75W 790-830 C Oil 60-62 HRC M3C, W-rich Blanking dies, jigs
SKD11, 12% Cr 1.5C, 12Cr, 1Mo 1000-1040 C Air / gas 58-62 HRC at 180-250 C Coarse M7C3 High volume abrasive blanking
SKD1, 12% Cr high C 2.0C, 12Cr 950-1000 C Oil 58-62 HRC Very high M7C3 Severe abrasion, short runs
8% Cr derivative 1.0C, 8Cr, 2Mo 1000-1030 C Air / gas about 62 HRC at 500-530 C Reduced M7C3, fine M6C EDM finished dies, heavy sections
Matrix die steel 0.5-0.6C, 3-5Cr, Mo, V 1000-1030 C Air / gas 60-62 HRC Fine dispersed MC, M6C High cycle sheet blanking
SKD12, 5% Cr 1.0C, 5Cr, 1Mo 960-980 C Oil / air about 60 HRC at 150-200 C M7C3, lower volume Long narrow punches, low distortion
Surface hardened 0.7C, 1Si, 1Mn, 1Cr Flame / induction Spray Above 60 HRC in case M3C in case Large trim dies, panel line tooling

Heat Treatment, EDM Practice and Dimensional Change

All of the air hardening grades in the table benefit from a controlled cycle rather than a single ramp. A typical schedule for a 12% Cr or 8% Cr die block is: stress relief of the rough machined block at about 650-700 C before finish machining, preheat in two steps to 800-850 C, austenitise at the grade-specific temperature, gas quench at a rate sufficient to avoid pearlite but slow enough to limit distortion, then double temper with an intermediate cool to room temperature between the two tempers. Double tempering is not a formality in secondary hardening steels; it converts retained austenite and stabilises the structure so that dimensional change during service or during a subsequent coating cycle stays predictable.

Electrical discharge machining deserves separate treatment because it is the most common cause of premature die failure in the 12% Cr class. The recast layer is untempered martensite with a hardness well above the base metal, and it is often microcracked. Recommended practice is to leave 0.02-0.05 mm of stock for removal by grinding, honing or a low energy finishing pass, and to temper the die at 20-30 C below its final tempering temperature after EDM regardless. In the 8% Cr grade, this post-EDM temper can be combined with the final temper because the steel retains hardness at 500-530 C.

Dimensional change on hardening follows the carbide content. Carbon tool steel quenched in water can move several tenths of a percent and distorts strongly, so it is used for small parts with grinding allowance. The 12% Cr grades change little in absolute terms but show measurable anisotropy related to carbide banding, which is why blocks are usually ordered with a specified grain direction. Matrix grades move least and most evenly, which is why they are preferred for plate stacks and for dies with closely toleranced dowel and pocket positions.

Purchasing, Inspection and Acceptance Points

Because several of these grades have no standard designation, the purchase order must carry explicit composition limits, delivery condition and acceptance tests. A workable acceptance package for cold work die steel includes: chemical composition verified by optical emission spectrometry on the delivered piece, with the 8% Cr grade showing chromium in roughly the 7.5-8.5% range and molybdenum around 1.8-2.2% rather than the 12% Cr pattern; annealed hardness, commonly specified at or below about 255 HBW for the 12% Cr grades and adjusted for the softer matrix grades; decarburisation depth measured on a cross section, since surface carbon loss destroys the hardness of a finished edge; carbide banding and segregation assessed on a polished and etched specimen prepared to ASTM E3; non-metallic inclusion rating agreed by a named method; and ultrasonic testing of heavy blocks where internal porosity or shrinkage would only appear after machining.

Hardness verification on the finished die should follow ASTM E18 for Rockwell testing, with the test location and the number of readings written into the drawing note, because a single reading on a decarburised surface will understate the true core hardness and a single reading on an EDM white layer will overstate it. Certificates should be supplied to EN 10204 3.1 so that the heats are traceable, and the certificate should state the tempering temperature actually used, not merely the hardness achieved. For comparative quotations, ask each mill to state the same four data points: composition of the supplied heat, delivery hardness, recommended austenitising and tempering range, and dimensional change observed in their own hardening trials at the section thickness being bought.

A frequent commercial trap is the use of the phrase improved grade without any numbers. Two mills may both offer an improved 8% Cr steel, one with 1.0C-8Cr-2Mo and the other with 1.1C-7Cr-1Mo, and the second will neither reach 62 HRC after a high temperature temper nor resist EDM cracking in the same way. Composition, not marketing language, is the only basis for equivalence. A second trap is ordering a matrix grade for an application that actually fails by abrasion; the die will look correct, harden correctly, and still wear out early because the failure mode was never matched to the steel family.

FAQ

Q: Is the 8% Cr cold work steel a standard JIS grade?
No. It is a derivative of SKD11 that is not listed in JIS G 4404, so purchase documents must state composition limits such as approximately 1.0% C, 8% Cr and 2% Mo instead of relying on a grade symbol.

Q: Why can the 8% Cr grade keep about 62 HRC after high temperature tempering while SKD11 cannot?
The higher molybdenum content provides strong secondary hardening through fine alloy carbide precipitation in the 500-530 C range, which compensates for the lower carbon and chromium that were removed to improve toughness.

Q: What hardness is normally expected from a matrix stamping die steel?
Matrix grades are normally supplied annealed and hardened to roughly 60-62 HRC in service, with the exact figure agreed between die builder and steel supplier according to the sheet grade being blanked.

Q: How much material should be removed after EDM before a die is put into service?
A practical allowance is 0.02-0.05 mm of stock removed by grinding or honing, followed by a temper 20-30 C below the final tempering temperature, to eliminate the recast layer and its microcracks.

Q: When should a 5% Cr grade such as SKD12 be chosen over SKD11?
SKD12 is preferred when low and even dimensional change matters more than abrasive wear resistance, for example long slender punches and multi-plate assemblies, provided the die does not need high temperature stress relief after hardening.

Q: What is the practical case depth for flame hardened die steel?
Case depth typically falls in the range of about 1.5-4 mm depending on nozzle travel speed and quench intensity, with hardness above 60 HRC at the surface and a progressive fall-off into the tough core.

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

phone

Email

Inquiry