Reading the Designation: A, D, E and F Are Toughness Classes, Not Strength Classes
Four letters carry almost all of the technical meaning in a hull plate order. In the ASTM A131/A131M system the first letter identifies the impact-test temperature band, the number that follows identifies the minimum yield strength level, and the letter H marks the higher-strength family. AH36 is therefore a 355 MPa minimum yield plate tested for toughness at ambient conditions, DH36 is the same strength level tested at 0 degrees C, EH36 at minus 20 degrees C, and FH36 at minus 40 degrees C. Purchasers who treat the four grades as interchangeable strength classes routinely accept plate that is metallurgically unsuited to the service temperature of the block it will be welded into.
The practical consequence is that the price and lead-time spread between AH36 and FH36 is not a marketing artefact. Moving from AH36 to EH36 or FH36 forces the mill into cleaner steel practice, tighter carbon and sulphur control, fine-grain treatment with aluminium plus niobium, vanadium or titanium, and in most cases a normalised or thermomechanically controlled delivery condition. Each of those steps adds rolling time, yield loss and testing load, and each of them is what actually buys the low-temperature toughness the structural designer assumed when the scantlings were calculated.
Chemical Composition: What the Specification Really Constrains
For the ordinary-strength family, Grade A is a plain carbon steel with carbon capped at 0.21% and manganese required at not less than 2.5 times the carbon content, which is a crude but effective way of guaranteeing a minimum manganese-to-carbon ratio for toughness. Grades B, D and E progressively tighten the same envelope. The higher-strength 36-series plates sit at a yield level of 355 MPa minimum and are normally specified with carbon at 0.18% maximum, manganese between 0.90% and 1.60%, silicon at 0.50% maximum, phosphorus and sulphur at 0.035% maximum each, and aluminium (acid soluble) at 0.015% minimum to pin the grain size. Niobium, vanadium and titanium are permitted as micro-additions, individually or in combination, and their total is normally limited by agreement because excessive micro-alloying raises hardness in the coarse-grained heat-affected zone.
Sulphur deserves separate attention because it drives through-thickness behaviour. At 0.035% maximum the plate is perfectly weldable in the plane of the surface, but a stiffened connection welded onto a 60 mm EH36 insert with through-thickness restraint can still delaminate if the inclusion shape is unfavourable. Where lamellar tearing risk is real, buyers write a Z-quality designation into the order and a sulphur ceiling of 0.010% or lower, together with a tensile test in the through-thickness direction and a minimum reduction of area of 20% to 35% depending on the Z class.
Mechanical Property Envelope and Charpy Requirements
The table below presents the acceptance values normally written into a purchase order for the four grades at thicknesses up to about 50 mm. Values are minimum requirements taken from the A131/A131M grade tables and common classification-society rule sets; individual class rules may add further requirements for thick plate, for plate intended for primary structural members, and for steels to be welded with high heat input.
| Property | AH36 | DH36 | EH36 | FH36 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Minimum yield strength, MPa | 355 | 355 | 355 | 355 |
| Tensile strength, MPa | 490-620 | 490-620 | 490-620 | 490-620 |
| Minimum elongation, % (200 mm gauge) | 21 | 21 | 21 | 21 |
| Charpy test temperature, degrees C | Ambient, not mandatory | 0 | -20 | -40 |
| Charpy average energy, J (longitudinal) | Not normally specified | 34 | 34 | 34 |
| Minimum single value, J | Not normally specified | 24 | 24 | 24 |
| Typical carbon equivalent, % max | 0.40 | 0.40 | 0.40 | 0.40 |
| Usual delivery condition | As-rolled or TMCP | Normalised or TMCP | Normalised or TMCP | Normalised, TMCP or quenched and tempered |
Two details in that table matter more than the headline numbers. First, the carbon equivalent formula used for the 36-series is C + Mn/6 + (Cr + Mo + V)/5 + (Ni + Cu)/15, and 0.40% is the ceiling most contracts quote; class societies frequently tighten it for thick EH36 and FH36 sections because a high carbon equivalent combined with a 40 mm plate and a 3 kJ/mm submerged arc pass is the classic route to a brittle coarse-grained zone. Second, the Charpy test is a set of three specimens, and the acceptance rule is normally an average of 34 J with no single specimen below 24 J, not a 34 J minimum for every bar. Mills that report only an average without the individual values are hiding the scatter, and scatter is exactly what predicts field failures.
Thickness, Width, Length and Dimensional Tolerance
Hull plate in these grades is commonly rolled from 5 mm to 100 mm, with the bulk of shipyard demand between 8 mm and 40 mm, widths up to about 3200 mm and lengths up to 12000 mm. Plate above roughly 50 mm in the 36-series becomes a different commercial proposition: the reduction ratio from slab to plate falls, the centre-line segregation band is more likely to be exposed during edge preparation, and ultrasonic testing of the plate body is often added to the order.
Tolerances are usually taken from the general requirements of ASTM A6/A6M or from EN 10029 for thickness, width, length, camber and flatness. For 20 mm plate ordered to a normal mill tolerance the permitted thickness deviation is small enough to be absorbed in the design, but for plate used in a nested cutting plan the negative tolerance is what destroys fit-up: a 20 mm nominal plate rolled at minus 0.3 mm to 0.5 mm short changes the weld gap across a 12 m seam. Buying to a restricted thickness range, for example zero to plus 0.8 mm, costs a small premium and removes an entire category of assembly rework.
Choosing Between AH36, DH36, EH36 and FH36
Selection is driven by the minimum design temperature of the structure, the thickness of the member, and the weld procedure that will be used. AH36 is adequate for internal structure, superstructures and secondary members in vessels operating in temperate waters, and it is the cheapest of the four. DH36 at a 0 degrees C test temperature covers the majority of conventional ocean-going hulls, including shell plating in moderate climates. EH36 at minus 20 degrees C is the standard choice for the upper decks and hull girder of vessels that trade in winter conditions, and it is the grade most often called out for offshore support vessels and for the ice-belt transition zone. FH36 at minus 40 degrees C belongs to Arctic and polar service, to LNG containment support structures, and to deck cargo areas exposed to spray in high latitudes.
A common error is to upgrade the grade without upgrading the weld procedure. A 40 mm FH36 butt weld made with a cellulosic electrode and a 4 kJ/mm heat input will produce a heat-affected zone whose toughness is far below the parent plate, and the classification society surveyor is entitled to reject the joint on the procedure qualification record even though every plate passed its mill test. Grade selection and welding procedure qualification have to move together.
Delivery Condition: As-Rolled, Normalised, TMCP and Quenched and Tempered
The same grade designation can arrive in different metallurgical states, and the state determines how the plate behaves in the yard. As-rolled AH36 is the cheapest and is normally acceptable because no low-temperature impact test is mandated. DH36 and EH36 are conventionally normalised at about 890 to 920 degrees C, which refines the grain structure and delivers reliable Charpy results but adds a full reheat cycle and a straightening operation. Thermo-mechanically controlled rolling achieves the same toughness without a separate normalising treatment by finishing the rolling schedule at a low temperature, and it is now the dominant route for EH36 up to about 40 mm.
Quenched and tempered delivery appears mainly in FH36 and in thick EH36 where a high yield-to-tensile ratio would otherwise cause problems. The trade-off is that quenched and tempered plate is far more sensitive to welding heat input: the tempering effect of the original treatment is lost in any zone reheated above roughly 700 degrees C, so a repair weld made without a qualified procedure can leave a hard, brittle patch surrounded by sound metal. When accepting quenched and tempered plate, ask for the tempering temperature on the mill certificate rather than the quenching temperature alone.
Welding Practice and Heat-Affected Zone Control
All four grades weld readily with shielded metal arc, gas metal arc, flux-cored and submerged arc processes. The controlling variables are carbon equivalent, plate thickness and restraint. A practical preheat rule used across many yards is 50 degrees C minimum for thickness above 25 mm, rising to 100 degrees C for thickness above 50 mm or where carbon equivalent exceeds 0.40%. Preheat is not a formality: it slows the cooling rate through the 800 to 500 degrees C transformation window, which is precisely the interval that decides whether the heat-affected zone ends up as tough acicular ferrite or as brittle grain-boundary ferrite.
Heat input should be held in a band, not merely minimised. For submerged arc welding of 20 to 40 mm EH36, a single-pass heat input of roughly 1.5 to 3.0 kJ/mm gives adequate fusion and a tolerable cooling rate. Too low a heat input produces hardness above 350 HV10 in the coarse-grained zone and a real risk of hydrogen cracking under a restraint-heavy joint; too high a heat input coarsens the zone and destroys the Charpy margin that the grade was purchased to provide. Post-weld heat treatment at 580 to 620 degrees C is not normally required for these grades below about 50 mm, but where it is imposed for dimensional stability it must be applied to the whole assembly, since a local stress relief creates a hard unmixed zone at the boundary of the treated area.
Inspection, Certification and Traceability
Every plate should arrive with a mill test certificate that links heat number, plate number, chemical analysis, tensile results, Charpy results with individual specimen values and test temperature, and the delivery condition actually applied. The certificate should state the classification-society approval mark where the order is for classed work, because class approval is granted to the steelmaker and the works, not to the grade in the abstract. Verification is straightforward: check that the heat number on the certificate matches the stamping on the plate, that the Charpy test temperature matches the grade letter, that the individual impact values are above the single-value floor, and that the tensile strength falls inside the specified band rather than merely above the minimum.
Where third-party verification is agreed, ultrasonic testing to a defined acceptance level is the most common addition for thick plate, and it detects centre-line segregation, hydrogen flakes and internal laminations that a tensile test will never reveal. Dimensional checks should cover thickness at several points per plate, squareness of cut edges, and flatness measured over a one-metre straightedge, because flatness deviation accumulates rapidly during nesting and fit-up.
Frequently Mis-specified Details on Hull Plate Orders
Four details appear repeatedly in poorly written orders. The first is a grade without a test temperature, which leaves the mill free to certify the cheapest interpretation. The second is a Charpy requirement quoted as an average only, without the single-value floor. The third is a thickness tolerance taken from a general mill standard when the cutting plan needs a restricted range. The fourth is an order that specifies EH36 but omits the delivery condition, so the plate may arrive as-rolled instead of normalised or TMCP and the weld procedure qualification will not be reproducible. Each of these costs less to fix on the purchase order than in the yard.
FAQ
Q: What is the main difference between AH36, DH36, EH36 and FH36?
All four are 355 MPa minimum yield higher-strength hull plates; they differ in the Charpy test temperature, which is ambient for AH36, 0 degrees C for DH36, minus 20 degrees C for EH36 and minus 40 degrees C for FH36.
Q: Does AH36 require a Charpy impact test?
AH36 is normally supplied without a mandatory impact test, which is why it is the lowest-cost grade; many buyers nevertheless add a voluntary impact requirement, and classification-society rules may impose one for specific structural members.
Q: What impact energy is required for EH36 plate?
The usual acceptance rule is an average of 34 J from three longitudinal Charpy specimens at minus 20 degrees C, with no individual value below 24 J; some class rules raise the average to 40 J or more for thick plate and for high-heat-input welding.
Q: Can EH36 be substituted with DH36 or FH36?
FH36 can generally substitute for DH36 and EH36 where thickness and weld procedure allow, but DH36 must not replace EH36 because the impact test temperature is 20 degrees C higher; any substitution needs design approval and, for classed vessels, plan approval.
Q: What carbon equivalent limit applies to 36-series ship plate?
The formula is C + Mn/6 + (Cr + Mo + V)/5 + (Ni + Cu)/15, and 0.40% maximum is the value most contracts specify, with tighter limits commonly imposed on thick EH36 and FH36 plate to protect heat-affected zone toughness.
Q: Is normalising always required for EH36?
No. Normalising at about 890 to 920 degrees C is the traditional route, but thermomechanically controlled rolling is widely accepted for EH36 up to roughly 40 mm and gives equivalent toughness with a finer grain structure and better flatness.
Q: How should thick FH36 plate be inspected on receipt?
Check heat and plate numbers against the certificate, confirm the minus 40 degrees C Charpy values including individual results, measure thickness at multiple points, and where specified review the ultrasonic test report for laminations and centre-line segregation.




