Mar 07, 2024 Leave a message

Warping Defects in Cold-Rolled Wear-Resistant Steel Plates: Root Causes and Mill-Side Prevention

Warping - also called skin lamination, peeling, or "skin rise" - is a surface integrity defect on cold-rolled wear-resistant steel strip. It appears as linear, layered or discontinuous M-shaped raised areas, mostly near the strip edges. Four root causes dominate: non-metallic inclusion accumulation, abnormal surface microstructure, subsurface gas bubbles, and oxidation channels. Each originates at a different stage of steelmaking, continuous casting, or hot rolling - and each has specific, proven countermeasures.

Key Takeaways

Inclusions from slag entrapment - the #1 cause. Accumulate at slab subsurface and delaminate during cold reduction.

Abnormal microstructure - a thin, hard martensite skin over a soft ferrite/pearlite core. The interface cannot survive cold-rolling strain.

Subsurface gas bubbles - CO from poor deoxidation or H₂ from wet refractories. Elongate during rolling and burst through the surface.

Oxidation channels - near-surface grain boundary oxidation during slab reheating. Open up as the slab is reduced in thickness.

All four causes are upstream problems. Once the cold-rolled coil is produced, the defective material must be scrapped - there is no post-rolling fix.

 

1. Warping vs. Flatness Defects - Know the Difference

 

It is easy to confuse warping (a material defect) with flatness problems like edge wave or center buckle (shape defects). The table below should clarify the distinction.

Characteristic Warping / Peeling Flatness Defects (Edge Wave, Center Buckle)
Nature Material integrity - surface layer delamination Shape - non-uniform elongation across width
Appearance Local raised areas, flakes, M-shaped lifting Continuous wave pattern along strip length
Origin stage Steelmaking → casting → slab reheating Hot rolling → cold rolling → tension levelling
Can it be fixed after cold rolling? No - scrap only Sometimes - by tension levelling or roller levelling
Detection method Visual + UT lamination check Shape meter (online) + visual

 

2. Root Cause 1 - Inclusion Accumulation (Slab Subsurface)

 

What happens

During continuous casting, mould flux (casting powder) can be entrained into the molten steel when the meniscus is unstable. These non-metallic inclusions - primarily CaO–SiO₂–Al₂O₃ slag droplets - are lighter than steel and should float to the top of the mould. However, turbulence from a clogged submerged entry nozzle (SEN), excessive casting speed changes, or sudden mould level fluctuations can drag them deep into the solidifying shell. They become trapped 2–15 mm below the slab surface.

 

When the slab is hot-rolled and then cold-rolled, these brittle inclusions do not deform with the steel. They fracture into stringers and eventually create a plane of weakness that separates under rolling tension - forming the characteristic raised "skin" or peeling defect found at the strip edges (where inclusion density is highest due to the final solidification point).

 

Prevention measures at the steelmaking stage

  • Stabilise casting conditions. Minimise speed changes and tundish temperature fluctuations. A steady meniscus is the single most effective countermeasure against slag entrapment.
  • Use the right mould powder. Select viscosity and melting rate to match the steel grade and casting speed. Low-viscosity powder penetrates more easily; high-basicity powder provides better lubrication but risks more entrapment.
  • Optimise SEN design and argon injection. A properly submerged nozzle with controlled argon flow prevents air aspiration and reduces mould-level turbulence. Clogging must be monitored and the SEN changed on schedule.
  • Employ tundish metallurgy. Weirs, dams, and turbulence inhibitors in the tundish promote inclusion flotation before steel enters the mould. A well-designed tundish can remove 30–50% of incoming inclusions.
  • Inspect and maintain slag-detection systems. Automatic mould-level control and slag-detection sensors must be calibrated regularly. Carry-over slag from the ladle to tundish is a common failure point.

 

3. Root Cause 2 - Abnormal Surface Microstructure

 

What happens

This defect arises when the hot-rolled strip surface develops a thin martensite case - typically 0.1–0.5 mm deep - sitting on a softer ferrite/pearlite substrate. The martensite forms because the strip surface cools too fast on the run-out table after hot rolling, quenching the austenite before it can transform to ferrite.

 

During cold rolling, the martensite layer (hard, brittle, elongation <5%) and the substrate (soft, ductile, elongation >25%) deform at completely different rates. The interface between them cannot accommodate the strain difference. Stress concentrates along the boundary, micro-cracks initiate, and the skin lifts - producing a peeling defect across the strip surface.

 

Prevention measures

  • Adjust steel chemistry. Increase manganese content (e.g., from 0.8% to 1.2% in CMn steels) to lower the Ms (martensite start) temperature and delay the transformation. This gives ferrite more time to form before martensite can appear.
  • Control run-out table cooling. Use laminar cooling with a controlled cooling rate instead of abrupt water quenching. A slower, more uniform temperature drop through the transformation range avoids a sharp hardness gradient at the surface.
  • Choose the right quenching medium. If through-hardening is required, brine or polymer quenchants give faster, more uniform cooling than still water, reducing the risk of a thin surface martensite layer over a mixed structure.
  • Apply post-rolling slow cooling. Holding the coil at 550–650 °C for a controlled period after coiling allows the surface and core microstructures to homogenise.

 

4. Root Cause 3 - Subsurface Gas Bubbles

 

What happens

Gas bubbles trapped just beneath the solidified shell of the continuous-cast slab are the third major cause of skin warping. The primary gas sources:

 

  • CO from insufficient deoxidation: When dissolved oxygen in molten steel is not fully killed by aluminium or silicon, it reacts with carbon during solidification: C + O → CO(g). The gas cannot escape through the already-solidified shell and forms elongated blowholes 1–5 mm below the surface.
  • H₂ from wet refractories: Moisture in the tundish lining, SEN, or casting powder decomposes at steelmaking temperatures, releasing hydrogen that dissolves in the liquid steel and comes out of solution during solidification.

 

During hot and cold rolling, these subsurface blowholes elongate in the rolling direction and eventually break through the surface, creating pinhole-like defects or larger peeling zones. The defect pattern often shows a longitudinal orientation parallel to the rolling direction.

 

Prevention measures

  • Ensure complete deoxidation. Target dissolved oxygen below 30 ppm before casting. Use aluminium-killed practice with adequate aluminium addition and sufficient holding time for Al₂O₃ inclusions to float out.
  • Pre-heat and dry all refractories. Tundish linings, SENs, and stopper rods must be baked at 1000–1200 °C per a documented schedule. Wet refractories are a guaranteed route to hydrogen pick-up.
  • Minimise air contact. Use argon shrouding between ladle and tundish, and between tundish and mould. Every second of exposed molten steel is a second of nitrogen and oxygen pick-up.
  • Design a correct tundish baking procedure. Specify ramp rate, holding temperature, and holding time. Record compliance - do not assume the procedure is followed.

 

5. Root Cause 4 - Oxidation Channels (Grain Boundary Penetration)

 

What happens

When the continuous-cast slab is reheated in the walking-beam furnace before hot rolling, the slab surface spends 2–4 hours at 1100–1250 °C in an oxidising atmosphere (excess air in the burner). Iron oxide scale forms on the surface - that is normal and is removed by the descaling spray. The problem is when oxygen penetrates below the surface along grain boundaries, forming a network of iron oxide (FeO/Fe₃O₄) channels that can reach 0.5–2 mm deep.

 

These oxidation channels are brittle and non-metallic. During rolling reduction, they do not weld shut or disappear - they open up as cracks and cause the surface to peel away in flakes. The defect is most common on slabs that have been reheated too long, too hot, or with a poorly controlled furnace atmosphere.

 

Prevention measures

  • Minimise surface cracks and defects on the slab. Grind or scarf slabs that show visible corner cracks, transverse cracks, or oscillation marks deeper than 1 mm. These surface discontinuities are the entry points for oxidation.
  • Apply anti-oxidation coating to slabs. Temporary protective coatings (boron-based or aluminium-based slurries) can reduce scale formation and grain boundary oxidation during reheating. This is especially useful for alloy grades with high Si or Cr content.
  • Control furnace atmosphere. Operate with the lowest possible excess air ratio consistent with complete combustion. Reducing the oxygen partial pressure in the furnace slows grain-boundary penetration.
  • Limit slab reheating time and temperature. Use the minimum time-at-temperature needed for uniform through-heating. Every extra 30 minutes above 1200 °C significantly deepens the oxidation-affected zone.

 

6. Summary - Prevention by Process Stage

Process Stage Defect Addressed Key Control Measure
Secondary metallurgy (ladle) Gas bubbles (CO) Complete Al-killing; O₂ < 30 ppm
Tundish Inclusions Flow control devices; stable level
Mould (continuous casting) Inclusions Stable meniscus; correct powder; SEN maintenance
Mould (continuous casting) Gas bubbles (H₂) Dry refractories; argon shrouding
Slab reheating furnace Oxidation channels Minimum time/temperature; anti-oxidation coating; grind defects
Hot rolling (run-out table) Abnormal microstructure Controlled cooling rate; Mn adjustment
Cold rolling All four Incoming inspection; UT lamination test

 

Frequently Asked Questions

 

What causes warping (peeling) defects on cold-rolled wear-resistant steel plates?

Four primary root causes: (1) non-metallic inclusion accumulation from slag entrapment during continuous casting; (2) abnormal surface microstructure - a thin martensite layer over ferrite/pearlite that cannot deform uniformly during rolling; (3) subsurface gas bubbles from poor deoxidation or wet refractories; (4) oxidation channels at the near-surface layer that open up during rolling deformation. All four originate upstream and cannot be corrected after cold rolling.

 

How can steel mills prevent inclusion-related warping?

Maintain stable casting speed and tundish temperature to avoid mould level fluctuation. Use optimised casting powder with proper viscosity and melting rate. Employ argon shielding and submerged entry nozzle (SEN) design to prevent air re-oxidation. Install tundish flow control devices (weirs, dams, baffles) to promote inclusion flotation. Conduct regular SEN and slag-detection system maintenance.

 

Why does abnormal microstructure cause peeling during cold rolling?

When the hot-rolled strip surface has a thin martensite layer (from rapid cooling on the run-out table) sitting on a softer ferrite/pearlite substrate, the two microstructures deform differently under cold-rolling reduction. The hard martensite cannot accommodate the plastic strain, causing stress concentration, micro-cracking and eventual delamination. Increasing manganese content and using controlled cooling can reduce the martensite depth.

 

What is the difference between surface warping and flatness defects like edge wave?

Surface warping (peeling/skin lamination) is a material integrity defect - a local delamination caused by subsurface discontinuities. Flatness defects (edge wave, center buckle) are shape defects caused by non-uniform elongation across the strip width during rolling, driven by roll gap profile and incoming strip crown. Warping is a steelmaking/casting problem; flatness defects are a rolling/levelling problem.

 

Does Gnee Steel inspect for warping defects before shipping cold-rolled wear plates?

Yes. Gnee Steel (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. performs visual surface inspection, ultrasonic testing (UT) for internal lamination, and dimensional flatness checks on all cold-rolled wear-resistant plates before dispatch. Mill test certificates (MTC / EN 10204 3.1) are provided with every shipment. Contact our quality team for your specific inspection requirements.

 

References

  1. Dhua, S.K. et al. "Metallurgical Analyses of Surface Defects in Cold-Rolled Steel Sheets." ResearchGate. 
  2. Huilaisteel. "Cold-Rolled Strip Peeling Defects: Causes & Prevention." 
  3. Cho, S.M. & Thomas, B.G. "Multiphase Flow-Related Defects in Continuous Casting of Steel." TMS 2020. 
  4. PMC / NIH. "Optimization of Continuous Casting for Preventing Surface Peeling Defects."
  5. Great-Pipe. "Main defects and control methods of cold-rolled steel plate flattening." 

 

All data above verified against cited sources as of August 2026. Please report any errors for correction.

 

Need Cold-Rolled Wear-Resistant Steel Plate with Guaranteed Surface Quality?

Gnee Steel supplies cold-rolled wear plates with full UT inspection and EN 10204 3.1 certification. Send us your grade, dimensions and surface quality requirements.

Send Inquiry

 

Or email info@gneesteels.com · WhatsApp +86 15824687445 · Tel: +86-372-5055135

 

China abrasion plate Manufacturers

China abrasion plate Distributors

Disclaimer: This article is provided for general technical information and does not constitute engineering advice. Gnee Steel (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. No.4-1114, Beichen Building, Beicang Town, Beichen District, Tianjin, China. All Rights Reserved. 

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

phone

Email

Inquiry