Choosing the right plastic die steel means evaluating five interdependent process properties-forging, machining, welding, heat treatment, and mirror polishing-not just hardness and price. A mold that machines beautifully but cannot be polished to Ra 0.05 μm is a rejected mold. This guide explains what each property means, how to specify it, and which steel grades perform best in each category.
Key Takeaways
- Forging: Plastic die steel must forge uniformly (good thermal conductivity, low deformation resistance) to produce sound mold blocks free of internal cracking.
- Machining: Pre-hardened grades (P20, 718, NAK80) can be machined directly. Free-cutting variants add S, Pb, Ca, or Se at the cost of slight polishability loss.
- Welding: Cavity damage repair by TIG welding is routine; preheat to 250–350°C and match the filler to the base grade.
- Heat treatment: The process must be simple and repeatable - good hardenability, low distortion, stable results. Vacuum hardening is preferred for polished cavities.
- Mirror polishing: The limiting factor is steel cleanliness. Grades produced by electroslag remelting (ESR) or vacuum arc remelting (VAR) consistently achieve Ra ≤ 0.05 μm.
1. Forging Performance
The first manufacturing step for a mold block is often open-die forging, which breaks up the cast dendritic structure, closes internal porosity, and produces a uniform, fine-grained microstructure. A plastic die steel with poor forging behaviour will crack at the edges, show internal bursts, or develop unacceptable anisotropy.
Good forging performance requires three things:
- Thermal conductivity high enough that the centre of the block reaches forging temperature without excessive soak time. P20-type steels (0.35–0.40% C, 1.5–2.0% Cr-Mo) have adequate conductivity for blocks up to 1,000 mm thick.
- Hot ductility sufficient to tolerate a forging reduction ratio of 3:1 or greater without edge cracking. This is primarily a function of sulfur control (≤ 0.005% for critical applications) and avoidance of low-melting-point tramp elements (Cu, Sn, Sb).
- Low deformation resistance at forging temperature (typically 1,100–900°C). High-alloy grades like S136 (420-type stainless with ~13% Cr) require higher forging loads than plain carbon or low-alloy grades.
For the mold buyer, the practical question is: was this block forged with sufficient reduction and from a reputable mill? GNEE Steel sources mold steel blocks from mills that forge with a minimum 4:1 reduction ratio and provide ultrasonic test reports confirming internal soundness.
2. Machining Performance
Plastic mold cavities are geometrically complex-deep ribs, contoured parting lines, cooling channels, and ejector-pin holes. The steel must machine predictably with both high-speed steel (HSS) and carbide tooling, and it must grind without burning, cracking, or loading the wheel.
2.1 Pre-Hardened vs. Annealed Supply Condition
| Supply Condition | Typical Hardness | Grades | Machining Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pre-hardened | 28–42 HRC | P20, 718, NAK80 | Machine directly; no post-machining heat treatment needed. Use coated carbide at moderate speeds. |
| Annealed | ≤ 230 HBW | S136, H13 (annealed) | Soft and easy to rough-machine; must be hardened and tempered after machining, which introduces dimensional change risk. |
Pre-hardened grades eliminate the distortion risk of post-machining heat treatment and are preferred for large molds. Annealed grades offer easier rough machining but add a hardening step.
2.2 Free-Cutting (Easy-Machining) Grades
For pre-hardened mold steel at higher hardness (32–42 HRC), small additions of sulfur (S), lead (Pb), calcium (Ca), or selenium (Se) form dispersed non-metallic inclusions that act as chip breakers. These "free-cutting" variants-designated with an "S" suffix, e.g., P20+S, 718S-can reduce machining time by 20–40% compared to the base grade [Ref. 1].
The trade-off is real: the same inclusions that break chips also create microscopic discontinuities that appear as pinholes during high-gloss polishing. Do not specify a free-cutting grade for a Class A (mirror) cavity surface. Reserve free-cutting grades for non-appearance surfaces: mold bases, support pillars, and structural components.
3. Welding Performance (Repair Welding)
Two scenarios drive welding on plastic molds: (a) a machining error that must be salvaged, and (b) in-service wear or damage that justifies repair rather than replacement. In both cases, the steel must accept a weld deposit without cracking in the heat-affected zone (HAZ).
Recommended practice for the common grades:
| Grade | Preheat | Filler Recommendation | Post-Weld Treatment |
|---|---|---|---|
| P20 / 718 | 250–300°C | Matching composition or slightly softer (e.g., P20 filler on 718 base) | Slow cool in vermiculite or furnace; stress-relieve at 30–50°C below tempering temperature if required. |
| NAK80 | 300–350°C | Special NAK80-compatible filler | Ageing treatment may be needed to restore hardness in the weld zone. Consult the mill's technical note. |
| S136 (48–52 HRC) | 350–400°C | 420-type stainless filler at matching hardness | High cracking risk; peen each pass. Post-weld temper at 200–250°C. |
Preheat temperatures are guidelines; the qualified welding procedure specification (WPS) for your specific part geometry takes precedence. Always test the repair procedure on a sample coupon that matches the base material and heat-treatment condition.
Rule of thumb: welding a polished cavity is a salvage operation, not a production method. The repaired area will rarely polish to the same Class A standard as the original surface. Plan machining to avoid the need for cavity welding.
4. Heat Treatment Process Performance
Heat treatment process performance refers to how reliably and simply a given steel can be hardened and tempered to its target properties. The practical metrics are:
- Hardenability: the depth to which the steel will harden in a given quenchant. P20-type steels with ~2% Cr-Mo have adequate hardenability for blocks up to ~500 mm in oil or polymer quench. Larger sections may require vacuum hardening with high-pressure gas quenching.
- Distortion tendency: minimized by (a) a low austenitizing temperature, (b) a slow quench medium (gas vs. oil vs. water), and (c) stress-relieving between rough and finish machining.
- Process stability: the steel should produce consistent hardness (±1.5 HRC across the block) from one heat to the next when the same cycle is followed. This is where mill reputation matters.
4.1 Quick Reference: Heat Treatment for Common Grades
| Grade | Type | Austenitizing Temp. | Quench | Tempering Temp. | Target Hardness |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P20 (3Cr2Mo) | Pre-hardened | N/A (supplied pre-hardened) | - | - | 28–32 HRC |
| 718 (3Cr2NiMo) | Pre-hardened | N/A (supplied pre-hardened) | - | - | 28–35 HRC |
| NAK80 (P21) | Age-hardened | Solution: 870–890°C | Air / gas | Age: 500–530°C | 38–42 HRC |
| S136 (420 mod.) | Through-hardening | 1,020–1,050°C | Oil / gas | 200–250°C | 48–52 HRC |
Always consult the mill certificate for the specific heat number's recommended cycle. Generic tables are a starting point, not a substitute.
5. Mirror Polishing Performance
For transparent, high-gloss, or medical-grade plastic parts, the cavity surface must produce a specular reflection-a true mirror finish. This is the most demanding process requirement and the one that most clearly separates commodity mold steel from premium grades.
5.1 Surface Roughness Targets
| Application | Target Ra (μm) | Recommended Grade |
|---|---|---|
| General-purpose (opaque parts) | 0.16 – 0.08 | P20, 718 |
| High-gloss (consumer electronics, automotive trim) | 0.05 – 0.025 | NAK80, 718 (ESR) |
| Optical-grade (lenses, light guides, medical) | ≤ 0.025 | S136 (ESR/VAR), NAK80 |
Ra values are targets achievable with proper polishing technique on clean steel. "Mirror" is commonly defined as Ra ≤ 0.1 μm [Ref. 2].
5.2 What Limits Mirror Polishing Quality
At Ra values below 0.05 μm, the limiting factor is not the polishing technique-it is the steel itself. Three metallurgical defects surface at this level:
- Non-metallic inclusions (alumina, silicate, sulfide). During polishing, the softer or harder inclusion is torn out or stands proud, creating a pinhole or comet-tail. The only solution is ultra-clean steel produced by electroslag remelting (ESR) or vacuum arc remelting (VAR).
- Microstructural banding (alternating layers of different hardness). The softer bands polish faster, creating a wavy surface (orange peel). Proper forging reduction and homogenization annealing minimize banding.
- Grain size non-uniformity. Fine, uniform grains (ASTM 7 or finer) polish more uniformly than mixed coarse/fine structures. NAK80 is specifically engineered for grain-size uniformity in the pre-hardened condition [Ref. 3].
Bottom line: if your mold requires Class A mirror finish, specify ESR or VAR material and budget for the cost premium. The difference between an air-melted P20 block and an ESR NAK80 block in polishing time alone can recover the material cost on the first mold.
6. Putting It All Together - Grade Selection by Priority
The five process properties are interrelated and sometimes conflict. The table below helps match the grade to your dominant requirement:
| Your Dominant Requirement | Recommended Grade | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Lowest cost, general-purpose molds | P20 (1.2311) | Widely available, pre-hardened, machines well. Acceptable polish for non-appearance parts. |
| Large molds, good polish, no post-HT risk | 718 (1.2738) | Improved P20 with Ni for hardness uniformity and polishability. The industry workhorse for large automotive molds. |
| High-gloss mirror finish, high volume | NAK80 (P21) | Precipitation-hardened, 38–42 HRC, ultra-clean microstructure. Designed specifically for mirror polishing. |
| Corrosive plastics (PVC, FR polymers) | S136 (420 mod.) | Stainless-type mold steel, hardened to 48–52 HRC. Resists HCl off-gassing from PVC. |
| Maximum machinability on pre-hardened | P20+S / 718S | Free-cutting variants. Do not use for mirror cavities. |
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between P20, 718, NAK80, and S136?
P20 (1.2311) is a general-purpose pre-hardened mold steel at ~28–32 HRC. 718 (1.2738) adds nickel for better polishability and hardness uniformity at ~28–35 HRC. NAK80 (P21) is precipitation-hardened, ultra-clean steel at ~38–42 HRC, engineered for mirror polishing. S136 (420 stainless type) is a corrosion-resistant grade hardened to 48–52 HRC for PVC and corrosive plastics. Selection depends on the plastic material, required surface finish, and production volume.
What Ra is required for mirror-polished plastic molds?
Mirror finish is generally defined as Ra ≤ 0.1 μm. General-purpose cavities target Ra 0.16–0.08 μm. Optical-grade molds (lenses, medical parts) require Ra ≤ 0.05 μm. Achieving this demands ESR or VAR steel; air-melted grades will show pinholes and inclusions at these levels.
Can plastic mold cavities be repair-welded?
Yes, by TIG welding with matching filler. Preheat to 250–350°C, slow cool, and stress-relieve if required. Repaired areas rarely polish to Class A mirror standard; welding is best treated as salvage, not a production method. Always test the procedure on a sample coupon first.
What makes mold steel "free-cutting"?
Sulfur (S), lead (Pb), calcium (Ca), and selenium (Se) are added to form chip-breaking inclusions. Free-cutting grades (P20+S, 718S) reduce machining time by 20–40% but compromise mirror polishing quality due to inclusion pull-out. Use them for non-appearance surfaces only.
Which Chinese standard covers plastic die steel?
GB/T 1299-2014 Tool and Mould Steels is the primary Chinese standard. Equivalent international standards include DIN 1.2311 (P20), DIN 1.2738 (718), AISI P20/P21, and JIS G 4404. Confirm which edition applies to your order.
References
- GB/T 1299-2014 - Tool and Mould Steels. National Standard of the People's Republic of China.
- Rapid Protos (2025). "Mirror Surface Finish: Ra Values, Cost & When You Need It."
- ASTM Steel (2023). "NAK80 Steel | P21 | 10Ni3MnCuAl Mold Steel."
All grade data and process recommendations were verified against the cited standards and manufacturer publications. Hardness values are typical; confirm with your supplier's mill certificate for the specific heat you receive.
Need P20, 718, NAK80, or S136 Mold Steel?
Tell us your grade, block size, and surface finish requirement. GNEE Steel supplies plastic die steel in plate and block form, cut to your dimensions, with full mill certification.
Or email info@gneesteels.com · WhatsApp +86 15824687445



Disclaimer: This article provides general technical guidance and does not constitute engineering advice or a product warranty. Process parameters are representative values; actual parameters depend on the specific heat, part geometry, and equipment. Gnee Steel (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. recommends that the user qualify all processes on sample material before production. No representation is made regarding the accuracy of third-party references.




